League General Discussion Thread

[gamerman01]

Ouch, that’s 4 experienced players that didn’t catch it.

Absolutely right, UK and China can’t collaborate until UK at war with Japan

---

(Edit - China can actually enter Burma before UK is at war with Japan)

[farmboy]

@gamerman01 actually I believe they can. I remember this coming up before and getting this clarified. A quick google search brought me this answer from Krieghund. THis is specific to pacific but I assume applies to global too.

https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/11100/china-question-re-uk-territories

[farmboy]

a couple of more links where this is discussed including a more recent one. https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/39961/chinese-fighter-and-burma
https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/16949/chinese-forces/9

[gamerman01]

I looked over the latest P40 manual and the FAQ, and they are both silent on the question, which really explains the different suppositions each of us have.

---

~~Then I’m glad I clicked on that most recent link (is actually an answer from just 2 months ago), and SHOCKER!

You move a single Chinese unit to Burma and Japan can’t attack Burma?!!
I guess normally there are no Chinese infantry in Yunnan, but the Chinese fighter to Burma makes a Japan attack on Burma impossible if Japan is not at war with UK - that is HUGE~~

---

(Edit: strike the above 2 paragraphs, I was temporarily confused)

[gamerman01]

Never mind, I guess if Japan was going to attack Burma, Japan would be declaring war on the UK anyway.

:p Confusing

[farmboy]

@gamerman01 it is a pretty significant thing though since China goes before UK. You can hide the fig there or help stack Burma before the Japanese declare war or without waiting a turn for the UK to declare war. I was definitely quite surprised when I learned it was an option.

[gamerman01]

Has anyone seen the flying tigers on an airbase and actually make use of the extra space? 🐸

[ArtofWar1947]

In PTV, how do the Allies win? Is an honorable victory achieved by capturing 14 VCs or must all three Axis capitals be captured?

[WindowWasher]

How often does the standings spreadsheet get updated?

[Adam514]

@ArtofWar1947 said in League General Discussion Thread:

In PTV, how do the Allies win? Is an honorable victory achieved by capturing 14 VCs or must all three Axis capitals be captured?

It’s the same as G40/BM, so 3 Axis capitals.

[axis-dominion]

@Adam514 said in League General Discussion Thread:

@ArtofWar1947 said in League General Discussion Thread:

In PTV, how do the Allies win? Is an honorable victory achieved by capturing 14 VCs or must all three Axis capitals be captured?

It’s the same as G40/BM, so 3 Axis capitals.

orr… when there’s no path to victory for the axis…

;)

[Adam514]

@axis-dominion said in League General Discussion Thread:

@Adam514 said in League General Discussion Thread:

@ArtofWar1947 said in League General Discussion Thread:

In PTV, how do the Allies win? Is an honorable victory achieved by capturing 14 VCs or must all three Axis capitals be captured?

It’s the same as G40/BM, so 3 Axis capitals.

orr… when there’s no path to victory for the axis…

;)

As it should be.

[gamerman01]

@WindowWasher When Roboto or I get on and see a result posted. Roboto’s been AWOL a few weeks

So Zero minutes to 72 hours normally

[gamerman01]

@WindowWasher You know we’re using an ELO spreadsheet and the old rankings system was discontinued 12/31/23, right?

[WindowWasher]

@gamerman01 Yep, i just won a game a week ago or so and it hasn’t been put in so i was just wondering

[gamerman01]

It looked a little different than posted games normally do, was small and inadvertently overlooked.
And MrRoboto and I have been entering and checking, he has been gone a few weeks so it’s just been me entering, with no checking, so overlooked, yes

[axis-dominion]

@gamerman01, can you add some wording to the bidding rules for the NG inf placement that has been a longstanding accepted exception to the normal bidding rules?

[gamerman01]

@axis-dominion

Sorry, no.

It’s an exception from the simple rule, which is why it hasn’t been listed.

If we change it, then there is potential confusion with the way it was.

It shouldn’t matter because the “default” is really just a starting point, it’s not actually a rule. And if players can’t agree on whether to allow it or not, you could roll a die, or maybe you shouldn’t play each other.

[Adam514]

If a nation that lost its cap plunders a cap, can they use the plundered money?

[Panther]

@Adam514 said in League General Discussion Thread:

If a nation that lost its cap plunders a cap, can they use the plundered money?

No, as the player skips all but the Combat Move, Conduct Combat, and Noncombat Move phases until the capital is liberated.