@simon33 Right, in that case the subs are incorrectly given that option. I have edited the issue accordingly. Thanks!

The “defending sub case” is special because here the battle ends without autodestruction. In the context of #1270 a retreat option had been given, as far as I remember.
The savegames work fine here, maybe you mixed 1.9/1.10 versions?

@SGT-Pitbull They have been deactivated a long time ago, see for example here:
https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/29193/signatures

You can edit your profile page, if you want. See “Edit Profile” and fill out “About me”. Also you can change your background image.

@simon33 said in TripleA engine - Known rules-related bugs/issues:

What about the retreat rules? Issue #1270. #2080 was reverted due to performance problems in #2544. So there’s still problems - if you attack and only have a transport or an AA Gun defending, you are still permitted a retreat.

Perfect! That is exactly what this topic is intended for: Those aspects simply get lost, if they aren’t listed anywhere and brought back to attention.

However, @simon33 , I retested the scenarios stated in #1270 (with 1.10.prerelease) and found only the “defending AA-gun scenario” not working correctly again:
defTrp.tsvg
defSub.tsvg
defAA.tsvg

The transport had correctly been autodestroyed and no retreat option was offered in my test.
The battle involving the defending submarine facing attacking fighters had been correctly ended without offering a retreat option, too.
But the remaining infantry facing a defending AA-gun only had incorrectly been offered the option to retreat.

Would you please verify? Meanwhile I have opened https://github.com/triplea-game/triplea/issues/4688 for it, referring to #1270.

@simon33 Thanks!

@Soviet-Steamroller said in New Industrial Complex placement.:

Long story short my question is '‘Can i build a factory on an island?’'

Yes, you can, provided it has an income value of at least 1.

@simon33 said in TripleA engine - Known rules-related bugs/issues:

Don’t forget mechs and tanks being able to pass through (blitz) through friendly neutrals, which they shouldn’t be able to do.

Which issue number is that? I will be happy to add this issue to the list.

This ignores added features which may be more important.

That is not the purpose of this list. My intention - as explained above - is to keep track on unresolved rules issues.

We can have a separate topic that lists features of course. Feel free to start it.
However we of course already do have this: https://triplea-game.org/release_notes/

@djensen
You mean you want to predefine “None” in these settings …


… with

https://www.axisandallies.org/

?

I think this would be most intuitive for the users, as this would maybe be the expected behaviour.

As of now the logo links to the identical view as the “categories” button next to it.

However it would make the home-button redundant. So this one could be removed, then.

I see,
@TheOperator said in Scramble planes belonging to friendly powers?:

@Panther Literally the one under “download and rules” on this website. But i checked a paper copy from a friend, and you’re absolutely right. The wording is as you say it is. Don’t know why the digital copy is different.

Actually that one is a bit outdated. AH has released an edited version I think back in 2016. Find the latest versions here:
https://avalonhill.wizards.com/rules

What rulebook are you exactly referring to,

@TheOperator ?

Actually it is exactly the same text, here:

Rulebook Europe 1940.2, page 16, Scramble section, 2nd clause, last sentence:

Air units belonging to powers friendly to the attacked power may be scrambled by their owner if
the owning power is at war with the attacking power, so long as the limit of 3 total air units is respected.