If you could create a super-group…

[johnnymarr]

That said, I am surprised at your contemplation of Clapton over Page, however brief… Clapton is an icon, but is not nearly as heavy or innovative as Jimmy Page. Wouldn’t have suited Led Zeppelin in my opinion.

The only reason for this was i needed Bonham.  I think Page is better than Clapton, but there is no one i’d rather have over Bonham.

Surprisingly, I have never listened to The Smiths before. With the power of Spotify, I shall do so tomorrow.

Be prepared.  Complete 180 from Zeppelin.  They are an aquired taste.

[Imperious Leader]

Bryan Ferry-Voice, Piano
Billy Curry- Electric Violin, Keyboards
Mick Karn- Bass, Sax
Florian Schneider-keyboards
Neil Peart, Yukihiro Takahashi- Drums
no guitars

[Young Grasshopper]

Slash - Guitar (GNR)
Steve Harris - Bass (Iron Maiden)
Kieth Moon - Drums (Who)
Bon Scott - Vocals (AC/DC)

[LHoffman]

@Young:

Slash - Guitar (GNR)
Steve Harris - Bass (Iron Maiden)
Kieth Moon - Drums (Who)
Bon Scott - Vocals (AC/DC)

Cooool… I considered Bon Scott myself, but went with Plant instead.

[Raymond Biesinger]

Helmuth von Moltke the Elder - rhythm guitar, vocals (Prussia)
Helmuth von Moltke the Younger - bass guitar, vocals (Germany)
Hannibal, Son of Hamilcar Barca - lead guitar, sax (Carthage)
General George S. Patton - drums (USA)
Napoleon Bonaparte - percussion (France)
Georgy Zhukov - mellotron, synths (USSR)

Yrs.,
R.

[Young Grasshopper]

@Raymond:

Helmuth von Moltke the Elder - rhythm guitar, vocals (Prussia)
Helmuth von Moltke the Younger - bass guitar, vocals (Germany)
Hannibal, Son of Hamilcar Barca - lead guitar, sax (Carthage)
General George S. Patton - drums (USA)
Napoleon Bonaparte - percussion (France)
Georgy Zhukov - mellotron, synths (USSR)

Yrs.,
R.

If you add Joan of Ark, it looks like the Wild Stallions band from Bill & Teds excellent adventure.

[Raymond Biesinger]

@Young:

@Raymond:

Helmuth von Moltke the Elder - rhythm guitar, vocals (Prussia)
Helmuth von Moltke the Younger - bass guitar, vocals (Germany)
Hannibal, Son of Hamilcar Barca - lead guitar, sax (Carthage)
General George S. Patton - drums (USA)
Napoleon Bonaparte - percussion (France)
Georgy Zhukov - mellotron, synths (USSR)

Yrs.,
R.

If you add Joan of Ark, it looks like the Wild Stallions band from Bill & Teds excellent adventure.

Ha! I hadn’t even thought of that.

Yrs.,
R.

[LHoffman]

@Young:

@Raymond:

Helmuth von Moltke the Elder - rhythm guitar, vocals (Prussia)
Helmuth von Moltke the Younger - bass guitar, vocals (Germany)
Hannibal, Son of Hamilcar Barca - lead guitar, sax (Carthage)
General George S. Patton - drums (USA)
Napoleon Bonaparte - percussion (France)
Georgy Zhukov - mellotron, synths (USSR)

Yrs.,
R.

If you add Joan of Ark, it looks like the Wild Stallions band from Bill & Teds excellent adventure.

How happy I am that this entered the thread. How appropriate.

I am surprised no one has taken Eddie Van Halen yet…

[Young Grasshopper]

@LHoffman:

@Young:

@Raymond:

Helmuth von Moltke the Elder - rhythm guitar, vocals (Prussia)
Helmuth von Moltke the Younger - bass guitar, vocals (Germany)
Hannibal, Son of Hamilcar Barca - lead guitar, sax (Carthage)
General George S. Patton - drums (USA)
Napoleon Bonaparte - percussion (France)
Georgy Zhukov - mellotron, synths (USSR)

Yrs.,
R.

If you add Joan of Ark, it looks like the Wild Stallions band from Bill & Teds excellent adventure.

How happy I am that this entered the thread. How appropriate.

I am surprised no one has taken Eddie Van Halen yet…

LOL, you guys are really showing your age.

[LHoffman]

@Young:

@LHoffman:

@Young:

If you add Joan of Ark, it looks like the Wild Stallions band from Bill & Teds excellent adventure.

How happy I am that this entered the thread. How appropriate.

I am surprised no one has taken Eddie Van Halen yet…

LOL, you guys are really showing your age.

I am only 22.

[poloplayer15]

keyboards-Geoff Downes (Yes)
drums-Keith Moon (The Who)
vocals- Paul McCartney (The Beatles) 
guitar-Jimmy Page (Led Zeppelin)
bass-Geddy Lee (Rush)

[LHoffman]

@poloplayer15:

keyboards-Geoff Downes (Yes)
drums-Keith Moon (The Who)
vocals- Paul McCartney (The Beatles) 
guitar-Jimmy Page (Led Zeppelin)
bass-Geddy Lee (Rush)

Very nice.

[poloplayer15]

thanks. its kinda hard picking just one for each category

[LHoffman]

@poloplayer15:

thanks. its kinda hard picking just one for each category

Yeah, I know what you mean. But I guess that’s the point. It can’t be too easy.

[General 6 Stars]

key boards - Ray Manzarek  ( Doors )
drums - Neil Peart  ( Rush )
vocals - Robert Plant  ( Led Zep )
guitar - Jimmy page  ( Led Zep )
bass - Geddy Lee  ( Rush )

[Gargantua]

Binyamin Netanyahu -  (Prime minister of Israel)  [On Vocals]
Ben Bernanke          -  (The chairman of the US Federal Reserve) [ On Drums]
Rahm Emanuel        -  (White House chief of staff) [Lead Guitar]
Sergey Brin              -  (Founder of Google) [Bass]

In a band called:
“The Juice”

[LHoffman]

@Gargantua:

Binyamin Netanyahu -  (Prime minister of Israel)   [On Vocals]
Ben Bernanke           -  (The chairman of the US Federal Reserve) [ On Drums]
Rahm Emanuel         -  (former White House chief of staff - now Mayor of Chicago) [Lead Guitar]
Sergey Brin              -  (Founder of Google) [Bass]

In a band called:
“The Juice”

“With these four Jews… dare I say it, I could rule the world.”

[hkytown1]

God, so many to choose from… :-o…here goes.

Layne Staley (Alice in Chains) vocals
Tom Morello (RATM, SSSC, Night Watchmen) guitar
Paul Gray (Slipknot, Stonesour) bass
Dave Grohl (Nirvana) drums

This whole lineup could change hourly :-D

[dinosaur]

… showing your age!!  I’ll show you some AGE! …

Paul McCartney … Bass
Billy Joel … Keyboards
Paul Simon … Guitar
Phil Collins … Precussion

Four lead singers that’ll never get along, but I’d have a tough time finding more talent in four musicians. - Dino