2012 - AAG40 League Rules

[Karl7]

Gamerman(Allies) over Karl7(Axis)

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28348.msg1012210#msg1012210

[Karl7]

Karl7(Allies) over MisterGreen (Axis) round 3

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28574.45

[U-505]

U-505 (axis) over jim010

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=27885.0

A life got in the way win.

[Karl7]

Hey Jen,

With less than a month away, is the league tournament still only for those with 8 games?  That’s fine with me, but according to Gamerman’s stats that means only me and MrGreen are up?  If so, it is 1 game then the league champion is declared or do we do best of 3 or what?

Also, I assume format is up to players – i.e. trippleA or battlemap?

[Karl7]

Karl7(Axis) over CmdJennifer(Allies), round 11 (I think) after fall of India.

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=27871.330

[Jennifer]

@Karl7:

Hey Jen,

With less than a month away, is the league tournament still only for those with 8 games?  That’s fine with me, but according to Gamerman’s stats that means only me and MrGreen are up?   If so, it is 1 game then the league champion is declared or do we do best of 3 or what?Â

Also, I assume format is up to players – i.e. trippleA or battlemap?Â

If it is just between you two (and you may be correct) I would say winner takes all.

[Jennifer]

Here are the rankings as have been reported:

Spoox: 1 Win
Karl7: 10 Wins
Mistergreen: 5 Wins
Questioneer: 2 Wins
AxisPlaya: 2 Wins
Jim010: 3 Wins
Seththenewb: 1 Win
Anchovy: 1 Win
U-505: 3 Wins
Gamerman01: 1 Win
Wheatbeer: 1 Win
Zhukov44: 1 Win

The league ends on Midnight, October 31st of 2012.  However, if I have the number of wins incorrectly recorded, please let me know by the 21st of October, 2012.

Unless the record changes, it appears that Karl7 will be playing MisterGreen for the 2012 champion title.  The game will start no later than 11/2/2012 and as soon as the record is finalized and both players agree to start.

The 2013 league will begin on the same day.  The only change to the rules will be that the most recent and “final” rules posted by Larry Harris will be in effect - as published on 11/2/2012.  (Previously it was as they were on 12/24/2011.)

An announcement post will be posted “shortly” (as defined by me. :P  )

[Fortress]

Shouldn’t the 2nd edition rules (the pdf was linked on the G40 thread) be the ruleset for the new league year? Everybody has access to them and I can’t imagine why we would want to play with a previous generation of rules when the current ones are here.

[gamerman01]

@Cmdr:

Spoox: 1 Win
Karl7: 10 Wins
Mistergreen: 5 Wins
Questioneer: 2 Wins
AxisPlaya: 2 Wins
Jim010: 3 Wins
Seththenewb: 1 Win
Anchovy: 1 Win
U-505: 3 Wins
Gamerman01: 1 Win
Wheatbeer: 1 Win
Zhukov44: 1 Win

You must not have compared this to my results spreadsheet or even double checked yourself, because these are wrong.

Karl has 9 wins, not 10
I have 2 wins, not 1
U-505 has 4 wins, not 3

Your list fails to identify who has played 8 games (besides Karl).
Last I checked, U-505 has at least 2 games in progress and so would qualify for the playoffs.  Then you will need to decide what to do with only 3 players who qualify for the playoffs, because the apparently this was not anticipated when the rules were done.  I acknowledge that you said “unless the record changes” but then you describe details about “the game” between Karl and Green, and that seems a bit presumputuous, to not even acknowledge U-505’s nearness to qualifying for the playoffs with more than 2 weeks to go.  Also, you have that provision for calling games by mutual consent at the end of the year that could cause the results to change at the very end.

You are making me lose confidence in the G40 league by managing things the way you do.  (Your “rankings” list is not in order, nor does it pay any attention to winning percentages which are specifically the criteria for the playoffs as per rule #9)

[Karl7]

U-505 may be in the mix?  Cool.  :-)

Anybody else even close?  Three way contest could be tricky.

[Jennifer]

Okay, I got a copy of the “2nd Edition” rules. Â

Gamerman01: That is precisely why I asked the players to double check.  I just went through this thread and recorded the results I saw posted.  I also acknowledge the season is not yet over.  I do, however, want to get the last 10 months recorded so I do not have to do it all on Halloween  :wink:

Revised Rankings:
Karl7: 9 Wins
Mistergreen: 5 Wins
U-505: 4 Wins (does this count our game, U-505 - or is Gamerman01 including this in his correction?)
Jim010: 3 Wins

Questioneer: 2 Wins
Gamerman01: 2 Wins
AxisPlaya: 2 Wins
Spoox: 1 Win
Seththenewb: 1 Win
Wheatbeer: 1 Win
Zhukov44: 1 Win
Anchovy: 1 Win

There are still games to be played.  Remember, the cutoff of reporting games for this year is Nov. 2nd.  If your score is not correct, as listed above, please notify me so I may correct it.

9 - Scoring/Playoffs
The top four players, with the best winning percentages (Must complete at least 8 games) will advance to the playoffs.

[gamerman01]

As I said, U-505 has 4 wins

Here is the link to my spreadsheet which has all the details already done for you.

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=25260.0

Just scroll down a bit to the last file attachment and download the Excel spreadsheet.  The last tab is the 1940 league tab.

[U-505]

@Cmdr:

U-505: 4 Wins (does this count our game, U-505 - or is Gamerman01 including this in his correction?)

I have 5 wins, now.

2 from Odonis, 1 from wheatbeer, 1 from jim010 and our game totals 5.

Speaking of our game: U-505(axis) over Cmdr Jennifer

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=27917.195

And wheatbeer(axis) over U-505

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28226.165

@Karl7:

U-505 may be in the mix?  Cool.  :-)

Anybody else even close?  Three way contest could be tricky.

Check wheatbeer. He took the rubber match in our 3 game set. And Axisplaya got me for 2, as well.

[U-505]

My bad. I forgot to post the second game against playa.

Axisplaya(axis) over U-505

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28308.90

[gamerman01]

Was that game with Wheatbeer the 2nd or the 3rd for 2012?

Thanks

[U-505]

That was the 3rd. I took 1 and then he took the next 2.

[DarthMaximus]

I’m going to unsticky to remove some of the clutter.
Looks like you are getting things ready for 2013.

I can resticky if you need me too.

[U-505]

@DarthMaximus:

I’m going to unsticky to remove some of the clutter.
Looks like you are getting things ready for 2013.

I can resticky if you need me too.

Actually Darth, this is the thread were we post the game results. You’ll probably want to wait until Nov 1st to unsticky this one.

[DarthMaximus]

Oh okay.  Thanks for the heads up.

[DarthMaximus]

Jen, is it okay to unsticky this now?