Yes for global we thought that the +2 damage would be too overpowered. So the 5 ipc defenseless stratBs roll at 1d6 there (the same way they do in 1942.2)
One issue I anticipate with the bomber change in isolation, is that it is comparatively simple/low cost for Germany and Japan to bomb the hell out of Russia. This is somewhat offset by the fact that those same Axis bombers can’t then be used in combat afterwards, and the fact Allies can bomb Axis in kind (especially Germany) with similarly cheap units, but I don’t know if the offset is really equal.
So much of this game still comes down to Russia just being too weak to stand on its own.
(I think in G40 UK Pacific has kind of similar issues. They’re like the mini Russia of the Pacific map. Always getting screwed by bombers, never with quite enough units to mount a proper defense, let alone offense. Pulling friendly units away from other uses like a magnet or a black hole haha)
At various points we have proposed different ways to shore up the Soviet position. These have been wide ranging. Everything from extra Russian units by default, to economic bonuses, to a NAP with Japan. Most recently my idea to close the Soviet Border with China in 1942.2. Those are more direct approaches.
Indirect approaches would be things like an A0 turn in 1942.2, or the M3 transport, as a way to give the US more options to open a second front, or send units to aid the Russians at the center.
For global similar ideas would be ways to directly strengthen the Indian position, again with objectives or more units or a different way of handling their economy. Perhaps a Chinese zero turn as an indirect method.
It’s hard to say which balance solution is best. But I think the defenseless bomber works as an independent concept. It just probably requires something else on top, if the goal is a game that is truly balanced by sides.
Ps. And of course, the defenseless bomber alone can’t solve the issue with Victory Conditions. I think that problem requires a separate solution, at least in Global. 1942.2 might work for the 8/9 VC spread, but the OOB global rules are kind of a joke, as we’ve discussed many times. Looking at the recommended victory conditions in G40, particularly for Allies, you can’t help but face palm hehe
:-D