Axis and Allies Europe 1940 2nd Edition ( AAE40.2) FAQ/question

[Spirou]

thanks for the answers

@wittmann:

I am afraid that until Russia or the US join the war, they cannot land air units or move ground units into another nation. They have to be at war.

yes, Russia and US can not move out, but how about UK units moving in? The rules only specifiy, that territories from enemys which are not at war are considered neutral instead of hostile. I found nothing about neutral or friendly.

@wittmann:

Subs do not stop naval movement( sea zones remain friendly) as you said. However, a Transport unaccompanied by a warship cannot unload in a hex with an enemy Sub.

but it can load?

[Witt]

On the turn you do your DOW you can load Transports and move them away to unload elsewhere.

yes, Russia and US can not move out, but how about UK units moving in? The rules only specifiy, that territories from enemys which are not at war are considered neutral instead of hostile. I found nothing about neutral or friendly.

It is the same thing. You cannot do it.

[Krieghund]

@wittmann:

Subs do not stop naval movement( sea zones remain friendly) as you said. However, a Transport unaccompanied by a warship cannot unload in a hex with an enemy Sub.

Actually, a transport may not offload in a sea zone with an ignored enemy sub during combat movement (for an amphibious assault) unless it is accompanied by a warship belonging to the same power.  It may offload during noncombat movement in such as sea zone without an escort.

[Spirou]

thanks for the answers @Krieghund and wittmann

[kcdzim]

@Spirou:

thanks for the answers

@wittmann:

I am afraid that until Russia or the US join the war, they cannot land air units or move ground units into another nation. They have to be at war.

yes, Russia and US can not move out, but how about UK units moving in? The rules only specifiy, that territories from enemys which are not at war are considered neutral instead of hostile. I found nothing about neutral or friendly.

No.  UK units are not permitted to move into Russian or US territories while Russia or the US is still neutral.

@Spirou:

@wittmann:

Subs do not stop naval movement( sea zones remain friendly) as you said. However, a Transport unaccompanied by a warship cannot unload in a hex with an enemy Sub.

but it can load?

It can load.

[Krieghund]

@kcdzim:

It can load.Â

Good catch.  I missed that before.  Subs alone never stop transports from loading.

@wittmann:

On the turn you do your DOW you can load Transports and move them away to unload elsewhere.

This is true in hostile sea zones.  Remember, enemy subs (or transports) don’t make a sea zone hostile, so you can always load in sea zones containing only them.

[Omega_Warlord]

Hey, my friends and I are playing our first game of A&A with 1940 Europe 2nd edition and have a question.

If more than one Naval Base service the same sea zone (example, build a naval base in Central US so that there are two bases servicing SZ 101) then can the US ships there move 4 spaces as each base adds plus one, or can they still only move 3 spaces as the don’t say the bases stack?

Thanks so much!

[kcdzim]

Bases don’t stack.

[Gargantua]

@kcdzim:

Bases don’t stack.

LOL could you imagine if they did?  A N.B. purchase in central USA would have you landing in uk everyturn!

[tbaz26]

Quick question about the rules in axis and allies europe 1940 SE pertaining to transports. Here is the senario. in round one, On italy’s turn, Great Britain has all of its mediterainian surface warships in sea zone 96(the zone around malta), and a lone transport sitting in sea zone 99 (off the coast of greece)with no allied aircraft capable of scrampling into sea zone 99. in other words, the british transport is a “sitting duck!” Italy has transports, and surface warships in sea zones 97 and 95.

Can Italy conduct an amphibious attack on british occupied egypt, by bringing its loaded transports, and possibly warships, from sea zone 97 through sea zone 99, to sea zone 98, and unloading their transports in egypt, WHILE at the same time sending one of its fighters or the bomber from southern italy, or even another warship, to sea zone 98 to take out the british transport? Or does the act of attacking the british transport in sea zone 98 create a sea zone battle and prevent the italian tansports and any other surface warships from passing through to egypt?

[kcdzim]

@tbaz26:

Quick question about the rules in axis and allies europe 1940 SE pertaining to transports. Here is the senario. in round one, On italy’s turn, Great Britain has all of its mediterainian surface warships in sea zone 96(the zone around malta), and a lone transport sitting in sea zone 99 (off the coast of greece)with no allied aircraft capable of scrampling into sea zone 99. in other words, the british transport is a “sitting duck!” Italy has transports, and surface warships in sea zones 97 and 95.

Can Italy conduct an amphibious attack on british occupied egypt, by bringing its loaded transports, and possibly warships, from sea zone 97 through sea zone 99, to sea zone 98, and unloading their transports in egypt, WHILE at the same time sending one of its fighters or the bomber from southern italy, or even another warship, to sea zone 98 to take out the british transport? Or does the act of attacking the british transport in sea zone 98 create a sea zone battle and prevent the italian tansports and any other surface warships from passing through to egypt?

Submarines and transports NEVER block passage.  You’re free to send a warplane to clean up SZ99 and still move units through 99 to 98.

[shootnscore26]

I know there are some differences with the sculpts in the 2nd edition from the 1st.  I have the first and I was wondering if it was worth getting the 2nd edition just for the sculpts…I just got a great deal for both europe and pacific and now I am questioning whether I should have spent the money on the 2nd edition…

Since the map is the same and I can download the 2nd ed rules, is there somewhere I can get the 2nd edition units in bulk instead of individually?  I looked on historical gaming and after you buy what comes in the game, you have spent more than buying the whole game new…

[Grossdeuschtland]

Do air units in AAE19402nd get to fire a casualty shot?

[kcdzim]

@Grossdeutschland:

Do air units in AAE19402nd get to fire a casualty shot?

Please be more specific.  All units get to fire a casualty shot except for naval units hit by submarines when sub rules are in effect.  Otherwise, any unit hit during the attackers round will fire in the defenders round.

Unless you mean after being hit by AA.  Units hit by AA are removed from combat without firing back.

[Guest]

Can you combine the version 1 gameboard of Axis and Allies Europe with the version 2 gameboard of Axis and Allies Pacific? I believe the board has remained the same. So it shouldn’t be an issue. I wanted to be certain however.

Cheers

[Krieghund]

Yes.  The Europe map has not changed at all.

[Gargantua]

@Krieghund:

Yes.  The Europe map has not changed at all.

Didn’t the Yukon territory get removed?

I mean, that’s a high traffic area!

[Sir_Cala]

okay question about amphibious assaults and scrambling.

europe map.

USA lands in Denmark and opens up the straight. Large navy accompaning US transports.

3 german planes in western germany did not scramble.

UK’s turn. Moves one transport loaded with land units from sea zone 110 has 3 movement.
transport moves into 112 and 113 wants to land in Germany when their are only anti aircraft in territory.
Note 1 movement left.
Western Germany scramble a plane.

I have always played that the transport is sunk.

Amphibious Assault Sequence
1. Sea combat
2. Battleship and cruiser bombardment
3. Land combat

Sea combat occured when the planes scrambled and made it a hostile zone.
Combat occurs. The defensless transport kicks in and the battle is over.

Defenseless Transports
In a sea battle, if the defender has only transports remaining and the attacker still has units capable
of attacking, the defending transports are all destroyed, along with their cargo. You don’t have
to continue rolling dice until all the transports receive hits. This will speed up combats. This also occurs if the only combat units remaining can’t hit each other. For example, if the defender has only transports and submarines remaining, and the attacker has only air units remaining, the air units and submarines can’t hit each other, so the transports are defenseless. At this point, defenseless transports are all destroyed, along with
their cargo. Attacking transports are not usually considered defenseless, since they generally have the option of retreating. If they can’t retreat, they are treated the same as defending transports. Destroying defenseless transports in this way still counts as combat for the purpose

So two questions?

1. Is the transport destroyed by the scrambled airplane since their was no naval support for it?

2. Can the transport retreat back to sea zone 112 before combat occurs?

I say yes it is destroyed and no it cannot retreat until one full round of general combat occurs.

General Combat Sequence
1. Place units along the battle strip
2. Submarine surprise strike or submerge
(sea battles only)
3. Attacking units fire
4. Defending units fire
5. Remove defender’s casualties
6. Press attack or retreat
7. Conclude combat

[Witt]

Afternoon Sir Cala.
The scrambling Fighter(s) would get one round of combat. If the Transport is still afloat, it can retreat one hex as you said. The cargo would still be on board.
The defensive transport rule only applies in defence. In attack it needs to be hit.

[Sir_Cala]

okay but what does this mean

Attacking transports … If they can�t retreat, they are treated the same as defending transports. Destroying defenseless transports in this way still counts as combat for the purpose

when would an attacking transport not be able to retreat?