Red Tails

[LHoffman]

@Jermofoot:

Honestly, I feel the discussion of old Lucas vs. new Lucas/CGI vs. old school special effects is silly.  The first point frim has already made.  I’d also add that everyone here discussing it is doing so through rose colored glasses.  I’d venture to guess that we were all younger and nostalgia gets the better of us when reflecting on old movies.

Perhaps… but isn’t that part of what age is for?  :-D    But in all seriousness, I (and apparently almost everyone else in the world) thinks trilogy 1 was better than the prequel trilogy. I realize that “which is better” is not the point we are discussing, but part of what makes the original better is the special effects. For whatever reason… Again, not the only thing, but I think a large portion. It just feels more real.

@Jermofoot:

Plenty complain about Lucas’ newest trilogy.  I thought they were bad, but still enjoyed seeing them

I still enjoyed seeing them too. I wouldn’t even call them bad, because I really do like them. It’s just that in comparison most people find Ep. IV-VI to be better films than I-III. I still enjoy watching them and there are a heck of a lot of memorable lines from Ep. I-III to quote among friends. … Most of which happen to be Jar-Jar ones, but that is a side note…

@Jermofoot:

in a galaxy of crazy creatures, Jar Jar does not seem that out of the question for me, and he was filling in for what the Ewoks were in ROTJ: kiddie attractions.

Perhaps that is true. They are equally bogus in real-to-life situations… but there is just that something extra about Jar-Jar Binks (and Gungans in general) which is comical/stupid to the point of embarassment. I am not sure that I can put my finger on it… Can anyone else here? I mean, you just see the guy and laugh because of how he looks, acts and talks… and not in a good laugh. His role of comic relief was overdone for what people expected to be a more serious film. All Jar-Jar jokes in our society today are about mocking the character because he is a blemish on the Star Wars legacy. Ewoks as furry aborigines are much more acceptable to me than, well, a Jar-Jar Binks is.

But hey, maybe Jerm is right and we are looking through rose colored glasses. It sure seems like most Star Wars fans are wearing the same glasses then, even those younger ones for whom Ep. I-III is “their generation’s” Star Wars. I am just saying that it seems a consensus about Jar-Jar Binks. But maybe history will prove us wrong and he will become like Yoda or something.

Sorry… this is a galaxy far, far away from the topic.

[FieldMarshalGames]

@Tall:

Jermofoot,

I’m not comparing old Lucas vs, new lucas.

I’m not looking through “rose colored glasses”.

I have REALLY enjoyed seeing some well-done CGI in movies.

And I don’t judge “RT” against anything other than normal standards.

But that being said,…

Red Tails is CR*P!!!

And I watch/collect ALL war movies, even if a lot of them aren’t very good, or were made in a time when the “special effects” of that era leave a lot to be desired.

But “RT” is embarasing. �

“Tall Paul”

Thanks for the Heads up….    I also collect WW2 movies.  I was looking forward to this one  :x

Guess I will leave a gap in my collection (right beside the empty space where Inglorious Bastards should be.

[militaryman077]

My brother and I saw it at a local theater the Friday it came out and he hated it because as he said it lacked action and didnt have surround sound. he gave it a “……” .lol

[Admiral_Thrawn]

I really liked it. It felt like an old school WW2 movie.

[Young Grasshopper]

@Admiral_Thrawn:

I really liked it. It felt like an old school WW2 movie.

If by old school you mean “Lassie comes home” or “Return to witch mountian” than maybe.

[Tall Paul]

You know, I agree that “Inglorious Bastards” was a bad movie, but I thought that it was only offerred up as a toungue-in-cheek kind of flick, not a real war movie. Something like that old Charlie Sheen “silly” navy movie with the old “Sea Hunt” actor. Sorry, I can’t think of his name and don’t have much time. It wasn’t really supposed to be a serious movie,…was it?

“Tall Paul”

[Gargantua]

The best part of Inglorious Basterds, is that the Bear Jew dies in the end.

[Clyde85]

Wow, I know the movie wasnt great but its not like we’re dealing with Transformers 2 here (I was really dissapointed by that movie, you’re supposed to wait until the 3rd instalment to really screw up a triology)

The movie wasnt great but I could kind of guess that going into the theater so I had adjusted my expectations accordingly. Thinking it was going to be awful I was pleasantly suprised how “good” it actually was. It never really had a “slam dunk” moment but made more then enough lay-up’s to win the game. I view the movie as kind of a throw back to those old celebratory action flicks that were made back in the hay-day of patriotic war films. It seems cheezy at times but I think red tails really harkens back to the guazy, broadly drawn American war films produced in the immidet after math of the conflict. Given that the Tuskeege airmen were often over looked for a long time post conflict despite having an exemplary combat record, I view Red Tails as a long over due tributre movie that just got left in a studio vault in 1946 and was only reccently re-discovered, dusted off, and made with little to no changes. Viewed this was the movie wasn’t all that bad to me  :-)

[Tall Paul]

Clyde85,

I understand your appreciation of their real life exploits, and I also take my hat off to those fine flyers. But there has already been a MUCH BETTER film made about them called “The Tuskeegee Airmen” that focused the spotlight on them.

I’m NOT in favor of heaping praise on any project or thing simply because of it’s political correctness.

This was a BAD film,…and as a film deserves to be called that.

Again, I repeat, I applaud the real-life “Tuskeegee Airmen”. I’m planning to paint one of my HBG P-51s in their scheme. And I’m NOT making any statement other than as a movie, this was a really BAD one.

“Tall Paul”

[Gargantua]

Sarcastic

When are we going to see a movie about some of the waffen SS divisions, and all their persecution after the war,  and all the challenges they faced getting in to the SS, because of the high standard of racial profiling, and correctness.

What a challenge that must have been, to prove family history back to 1750,  and the trials and tribulations they must have faced, in a world at war.

What a heart warming movie of human success that would be.

[Clyde85]

Tall Paul I think you misunderstand me, I wasnt saying it was good by todays standards, but rahter I was saying “Aim low and you’ll never be dissappointed”  :wink:  :lol:

[Tall Paul]

Clyde85,

OK, I understand what you just said.

But I don’t think it’s right to expect people to pay $9.00 and expect anything less than their moneys worth. This is simply a bad movie. I only paid $6.00 at a matinee showing,…and I still feel that I was “Ripped-Off”.

It really is a shame that these actors, who could have done a wonderful job if they would have been given a decent script. The script seemed like an eight year old wrote it and wasn’t the least bit enthused or realistic feeling.

I really enjoyed “Men of Honor” and I have a DVD copy of it. Great script, great acting, really good movie.

But RED TAILS is INSULTINGLY BAD!

“Tall Paul”

[Imperious Leader]

How can their be two pages of “red tails sucks” posts?

Is it that good of a movie to draw the concern?

[suprise attack]

To many of todays movies dont have any story. I think they should have showed how tough it was to become a pilot being black and also the lack of equallity when it was all said and done and they came home. Tuskegee air men was a good movie, you would think they would have made the next one better. I think too many people want to see things blown up every 3 seconds or they think it sucks.
  If you ever happen to meet any of the surviving RED TAILS take your hat off and say thank you

[Tall Paul]

I watched “The Tuskeegee Airmen” again last night. What a difference between this movie and “R.T.” The Tuskeegee Airmen had a well-written script, good actors doing a good job of acting(including Cuba Gooding) and a much better atmosphere of a war film. IMHO “R.T.” fails on even being considered a decent film. It’s just BAD!

“Tall Paul”

[ABWorsham4]

What’s your thoughts on the recent claims that the Tuskeegee Airmen perfect bomber protection record wasn’t perfect?

[Tall Paul]

It wasn’t PERFECT. But they still have an EXCELLENT record, and I’m PROUD of their acomplishments as I’m sure the bomber crews they protected were.

“Tall Paul”