AAG40 FAQ

[Krieghund]

@moralecheck:

Or…does it mean if the Russians attack Japan first, but not near Mongolia, that Mongolia will still activate if Japan counter attacks in one of the Russian territories next to Mongolia?

That’s what it means.

[moralecheck]

Perfect thanks.  So if Russia attacks Japan from a territory border mongolia, then mongolia will not activate at all, even if Japan pushes back into Russia.

[Tyzoq]

Can Japan build a major IC in Chinese territory they originally controlled at the start of the game?

[Tyzoq]

Just found this…

@Krieghund:

Territories with Chinese symbols printed on them are original Chinese territories, so Japan may not build major ICs on them.

[Jennifer]

@Tyzoq:

Can Japan build a major IC in Chinese territory they originally controlled at the start of the game?

No, as you found.  Japan can ONLY build a major complex in Korea or upgrade the complex in Japan to a major complex should they liberate their homeland.

[Gargantua]

It is my understanding that you cannot load your transport if it starts in a sea zone with enemy ships.

Does that include SUBS?

[Gargantua]

Also,

Can you ATTACK your own pro-blank neutrals?  And yes there is a reason to do this and it’s important…

[diogom]

Hello.

I have i doubt in alpha 3.

Can i build a major IC in Manchuria or Kwandi (Shangai) as Japan? In the continental china where can japan build an Major IC? Only in Korea? I´m continuing a game this afternoon and the japan player did that, and i´m not sure if it is legal or nor in alpha 3.
Thanks

[Jennifer]

@Gargantua:

It is my understanding that you cannot load your transport if it starts in a sea zone with enemy ships.

Does that include SUBS?

Transports and submarines can be ignored.  So, as much as Gamerman hates it when I say this, I THINK submarines don’t block transport loading/offloading and only effect movement if the transport ends its turn in the sea zone without surface warships to protect it.

---

@Gargantua:

Also,

Can you ATTACK your own pro-blank neutrals?  And yes there is a reason to do this and it’s important…

The instant your forces move in, they surrender.

---

@diogom:

Hello.

I have i doubt in alpha 3.

Can i build a major IC in Manchuria or Kwandi (Shangai) as Japan? In the continental china where can japan build an Major IC? Only in Korea? I´m continuing a game this afternoon and the japan player did that, and i´m not sure if it is legal or nor in alpha 3.
Thanks

As I said above, Japan can ONLY build a new major complex in Korea.

[diogom]

My doubt is because of this frase in bold from the alpha 3.

Industrial Complexes:
Major industrial complexes can only be built on originally controlled territories (this includes upgrading minor ones). Likewise they may not be upgraded when captured. Major industrial complexes are reduced to minor when captured. The original owner of the territory may upgrade it if the territory is recaptured.

Originally controled… not owned! japan originaly control manchuria…

[BigBadBruce]

Subs block offloading if transports are alone (without surface warship). If surface warship present, in “offload” sea zone, then subs are ignored and transports can offload.

Transports can load in a ennemy sea zone only if they start in that zone and only if the “moving player” declared war in that (his) specific turn. I was surprised, but that was once played against me. Otherwise I think they are blocked, but official answer would be nice.

I don’t think you can attack your pro-neutral. The only reason I see for this is because you want to blitz thru…. or move in during combat moves so other units (like MInf) can drive thru during non-combat moves. I was once told by Krieghund that you can’t blitz thru. So I guess there’s no way you can actually attack (move during combat move).

[Krieghund]

@diogom:

Originally controled… not owned! japan originaly control manchuria…

“Controlled” and “owned” are the same thing.

@BigBadBruce:

Subs block offloading if transports are alone (without surface warship). If surface warship present, in “offload” sea zone, then subs are ignored and transports can offload.

Subs only block offloading for amphibious assaults. They never block offloading into friendly or friendly neutral territories.

@BigBadBruce:

Transports can load in a ennemy sea zone only if they start in that zone and only if the “moving player” declared war in that (his) specific turn. I was surprised, but that was once played against me.

Correct, except this should say “hostile sea zone” rather than “enemy sea zone”.  Enemy subs and/or transports don’t make a sea zone hostile.

@BigBadBruce:

I don’t think you can attack your pro-neutral.

Correct.

[Jennifer]

@diogom:

My doubt is because of this frase in bold from the alpha 3.

Industrial Complexes:
Major industrial complexes can only be built on originally controlled territories (this includes upgrading minor ones). Likewise they may not be upgraded when captured. Major industrial complexes are reduced to minor when captured. The original owner of the territory may upgrade it if the territory is recaptured.

Originally controled… not owned! japan originaly control manchuria…

No, we have been informed that Chinese territories that Japan begins the game in control over do NOT satisfy the originally owned territories restrictions on major complexes.  It literally has to be a territory you OWN, not one that is conquered.  Think of it this way:  If the territory can only be liberated, then you do not own it, you conquered it. (Assuming friendly capitol is not under enemy control.)  KSU, MAN, etc can ONLY be liberated, it can never be taken by the British, Australians, French, Russians or Americans.

[Ruanek]

@moralecheck:

Perfect thanks.  So if Russia attacks Japan from a territory border mongolia, then mongolia will not activate at all, even if Japan pushes back into Russia.

Except if when Japan pushes back into Russia that includes a territory next to Mongolia.

[Jennifer]

@Ruanek:

@moralecheck:

Perfect thanks.  So if Russia attacks Japan from a territory border mongolia, then mongolia will not activate at all, even if Japan pushes back into Russia.

Except if when Japan pushes back into Russia that includes a territory next to Mongolia.

Comical Situation:

1)  Russia is taken over except for the territories bordering Mongolia. 
2)  There are no Russian units anywhere on the board.

If Japan attacks Amur, do the Mongols still join Russia?  Is it still Russia?  What if they liberate Moscow?  Is it now the Great Mongol Empire of 1943?  Do the Mongols say “just kidding, we were really members of the United Soviet Socialist Republics all along!”?

Sorry, but that seems VERY funny to me.  I know that literally, the rules say the Mongols are now Russians and can liberate Moscow to make Russia a nation again, I just dont see the Tom, Dick and Harry’s of Mongolia suddenly “liberating” Russia and calling themselves Russian.

[Gargantua]

Those are the rules of the game,  but if you’ve taken moscow, those russian infantry aren’t going to be liberating it.  Ever.

[moralecheck]

@Ruanek:

@moralecheck:

Perfect thanks.  So if Russia attacks Japan from a territory border mongolia, then mongolia will not activate at all, even if Japan pushes back into Russia.

Except if when Japan pushes back into Russia that includes a territory next to Mongolia.

But…but…"If the Soviet Union attacks any Japanese-controlled territory bordering these Mongolian territories while Mongolia is still neutral, Mongolia will remain neutral and not ally itself with the Soviet Union. "  I feel like one of those computers that Captain Kirk blew up in the original series by confusing it to death.  :cry:

[Krieghund]

You’re right, moralecheck, and Ruanek is wrong.

[moralecheck]

@Krieghund:

You’re right, moralecheck, and Ruanek is wrong.

Thanks KH. :)

[Ruanek]

@Krieghund:

You’re right, moralecheck, and Ruanek is wrong.

Sorry, I misunderstood the rules and how they related to the map.  I forgot that Japan has territories next to Mongolia.