L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7)

[666]

@nikola1975 said in L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7):

@666

Yes, sorry.
666-vs-nikola-g6 scramble.tsvg

no thanks

[666]

@nikola1975 said in L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7):

@666

Yes, sorry.
666-vs-nikola-g6 scramble.tsvg

actally if you see this in time I will scramble three fgt’s to morocco

[nikola1975]

@666

Hm, I just came back to ask. I thought it is possible to scramble from the carriers only to the territories with defending land units. I know that TripleA engine does not respect all the rules, so I am not sure now? Do you know?

In case it is possible to scramble to defend planes, would you mind me taking the fighter back, obviously I would not make that attack in that case?

[666]

@nikola1975 said in L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7):

@666

Hm, I just came back to ask. I thought it is possible to scramble from the carriers only to the territories with defending land units. I know that TripleA engine does not respect all the rules, so I am not sure now? Do you know?

In case it is possible to scramble to defend planes, would you mind me taking the fighter back, obviously I would not make that attack in that case?

I assume that aircraft can be scrambled to defend land and air units. I’ll ask for clarification and if they can be scrambled then yes, you can redo your turn.

[nikola1975]

@666

I will pull it back. Even if it can’t scramble, and you have assumed it can, it would not be fair to you.

[nikola1975]

@nikola1975

But if you find out about it, let me know anyway.

666-vs-nikola-g6.tsvg

[666]

@nikola1975 said in L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7):

@666

I will pull it back. Even if it can’t scramble, and you have assumed it can, it would not be fair to you.

you don’t need to do that, the best to learn from a mistake is to be bitten.

[nikola1975]

@666 Well, I posted the move, so let’s continue from there.

[666]

@nikola1975 said in L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7):

@666 Well, I posted the move, so let’s continue from there.

This is from Simon…about 4 hours ago
Yes I am pretty sure. They updated the notes on land scrambles to include air units being enough to allow the scramble a while back. Can’t imagine that CVs would be excluded. Although I am not the arbiter.

I could ask Gamerman and/or Adam fro a definitive ruling if you’d like. Let me know.

[nikola1975]

@666 Yes, I have read the game notes again. You are right, they would have mentioned it specifically if it was the case, as there are remarks related to seazone scramblings.

Sorry about the mess.

[666]

@nikola1975 said in L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7):

@666 Yes, I have read the game notes again. You are right, they would have mentioned it specifically if it was the case, as there are remarks related to seazone scramblings.

Sorry about the mess.

No worries, I make mistakes all the time. Feel free to redo your G turn.

[nikola1975]

@666

It is a correct move I sent yesterday, you can play it from there.

[666]

@nikola1975 666-vs-nikola-R6.tsvg

[666]

@nikola1975 666-vs-nikola-R6A.tsvg

Please use this file, second time I forgot to move that FRE dd. Thanks

[nikola1975]

@666

You are pressing me well in the Pacific. American carrier with ANZAC plane is another one of those moves I need to remember. With those Russian subs, you have done lot of damage to the Japanese navy.

666-vs-nikola-j6.tsvg

[666]

@nikola1975 said in L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7):

@666

You are pressing me well in the Pacific. American carrier with ANZAC plane is another one of those moves I need to remember. With those Russian subs, you have done lot of damage to the Japanese navy.

666-vs-nikola-j6.tsvg

you should also be paying more attention to the NO’s, and making small changes to your purchases and strategies to take these away from your opponents.

[nikola1975]

@666

Well, I am trying. I have learned that NOs are extremely important for PtV, especially in the Pacific, but I am not managing to take them and hold them. Usually I first go for South Pacific islands and take Guam in the round that Japan attacks, but this was stopped now due to Soviet subs. Now, missing another 2 transports to do that.

Not sure about purchases though, I guess I am not seeing everything yet.

[666]

@nikola1975 said in L22 PtV 666 (allies) vs Nikola1975 (ax+7):

@666

Well, I am trying. I have learned that NOs are extremely important for PtV, especially in the Pacific, but I am not managing to take them and hold them. Usually I first go for South Pacific islands and take Guam in the round that Japan attacks, but this was stopped now due to Soviet subs. Now, missing another 2 transports to do that.

Not sure about purchases though, I guess I am not seeing everything yet.

it’s easy enough to stop R from getting some of theirs with the purchase of subs by G & J and parking them in certain sea zones. Same with preventing some UK NO’s, my comment wasn’t so much about taking them as them axis but preventing the allies from getting theirs. Just something I noticed as we played.

[666]

@nikola1975 I have decided against any axis scrambles here as the odds are overwhelming but if you want to scramble we can re-roll that battle. Just let me know.

[666]

@nikola1975 666-vs-nikola-UK6.tsvg