L12G40 Karl7(Axis) vs Jimi010(Allies) -7 Bid (Axis)

[jim010]

US

Buys

3 inf, 2 TT, 1 CV, 1 fht,  DD

CM

sz34 to sz42
1 sb

sz54 to sz42
1 BB, 2 CA, 2 DD, 2 CV, 3 fht, 1 tac

sz91 to sz104
2 fht, 1 sb

Mor to Alg
1 inf

[jim010]

I will have 1 more sb in sz42.  I just need to check the rules on redoing a battle.

[Karl7]

I would think if you are going forward with battle anyway then corrected map makes no difference otherwise you’d get basically a rerole on a technicality.  I think you basically get the chance to withdraw or continue. But maybe we need an official ruling

[Karl7]

Or you could just include the extra sub role round one, then chose it as a casualty, so you get a units/hit point back for round 2.

[Karl7]

I thought this issue was interesting enough to ask the moderators…

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=25277.0

[Karl7]

Cmd Jennifer replied

you got it, you can rerole whole thing… if the dice gods are just, you will crush me!

[jim010]

Yes, I got the same response.  If this were not a league game, I wouldn’t have bothered to get a ruling, but I thought I should ask as it may come up in other games.

I wouldn’t fret, though, as it is not the Pacific side you’ll get your win.  You have a win coming to you on the Europe side.  This battle won’t change things.

I’ll have to reroll later, though, as I have guests coming.

[jim010]

Battle of sz42
1 sb, 2 DD, 2 CA, 1 BB, 3 fht, 1 tac, 2 CV vs 2 DD, 2 CV, 2 CA, 2 BB, 2 fht, 2 tac

att
Rolls: 3@2 5@3 2@4; Total Hits: 33@2: (2, 5, 5)5@3: (6, 6, 4, 6, 3)2@4: (4, 5)

[jim010]

You don’t need to give me losses.

2 BB, 1 CV damaged.

def

Rolls: 4@2 4@3 4@4; Total Hits: 54@2: (5, 5, 4, 3)4@3: (1, 1, 2, 5)4@4: (4, 5, 5, 4)

[Karl7]

Good lord!

[jim010]

sz42 2

att
Rolls: 3@2 5@3 2@4; Total Hits: 23@2: (4, 4, 4)5@3: (6, 6, 3, 5, 4)2@4: (6, 1)

[jim010]

Losses?

[Karl7]

hmm, so I have 1 cv left with hit points?

let me look at the map a second

[Karl7]

I am lost a little

you got 2, then I got 5, but you are still rolling exact same amount round 2?  shouldn’t you have 2 less after taking all hit points? Or am I missing something?

[jim010]

Yup, you are right.  I didn’t lose a DD.

I missed with the 2s anyway.  I doubt you want me to reroll.

[Karl7]

Ok, no that is fine.  I was just confused

so you lost and ss, and dd round 1?  Makes a difference as to if I keep a dd or take a hit to my other cv

[jim010]

2 CV, 1 DD

[Karl7]

Thanks, ok that clears it all up.

I will lose hit to cv, and dd

[jim010]

def
Rolls: 4@2 4@3 4@4; Total Hits: 64@2: (1, 5, 3, 5)4@3: (4, 1, 4, 6)4@4: (3, 2, 1, 1)

[jim010]

Survive with 2 fht, 1 tac.  Retreat to Nte