L12G40 Karl7(Axis) vs Jimi010(Allies) -7 Bid (Axis)

[jim010]

def
Rolls: 4@2 4@3 4@4; Total Hits: 74@2: (2, 3, 4, 2)4@3: (6, 3, 1, 5)4@4: (1, 3, 3, 6)

[jim010]

Oww.

lose both CV, dmg 1 BB lose 2 DD

sz42 2

att
Rolls: 5@3 2@4; Total Hits: 45@3: (6, 2, 2, 3, 6)2@4: (6, 1)

[jim010]

losses?

[Karl7]

ok, hmmm…

[Karl7]

Ag, I noticed the map you are using is all screwed up… alas
it has some of my ncm’s from my turn but not all, also it does not have ANY of my units placements that I can see…

This is my fault… :roll:

so, I do not think i blocked 55,45 even as I posted so that battle going can stand, but it would call into question whether your anzac fleet could survive a counter attack… effecting your planning etc

so I think you have two options

(1) allow me to post new map with ncms as I originally posted them with unit placements

or

(2) or withdraw you battle and allow me to redo Japan ncms…

your choice I think

[Karl7]

so just to clarify, you can either allow me to post a finished map per my posted moves, which would allow the battle as is to continue or you can withdraw your US combat moves, allow Japan to redo its ncm moves and then go….

Given its my screw up I think you get that advantage

[jim010]

Hmm.

Post the proper map as it should have been.  I think that is fair.

But I will need to look at it and see if I would still have gone through with the battle.

[Karl7]

coming up

[Karl7]

proper map!

Jimi010(allies)_v._Karl7(axis)_05cJapan.AAM

[Karl7]

so, in any event, losses are 2cv, 2dds if battle continues.

:-D

[jim010]

US

Buys

3 inf, 2 TT, 1 CV, 1 fht,  DD

CM

sz34 to sz42
1 sb

sz54 to sz42
1 BB, 2 CA, 2 DD, 2 CV, 3 fht, 1 tac

sz91 to sz104
2 fht, 1 sb

Mor to Alg
1 inf

[jim010]

I will have 1 more sb in sz42.  I just need to check the rules on redoing a battle.

[Karl7]

I would think if you are going forward with battle anyway then corrected map makes no difference otherwise you’d get basically a rerole on a technicality.  I think you basically get the chance to withdraw or continue. But maybe we need an official ruling

[Karl7]

Or you could just include the extra sub role round one, then chose it as a casualty, so you get a units/hit point back for round 2.

[Karl7]

I thought this issue was interesting enough to ask the moderators…

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=25277.0

[Karl7]

Cmd Jennifer replied

you got it, you can rerole whole thing… if the dice gods are just, you will crush me!

[jim010]

Yes, I got the same response.  If this were not a league game, I wouldn’t have bothered to get a ruling, but I thought I should ask as it may come up in other games.

I wouldn’t fret, though, as it is not the Pacific side you’ll get your win.  You have a win coming to you on the Europe side.  This battle won’t change things.

I’ll have to reroll later, though, as I have guests coming.

[jim010]

Battle of sz42
1 sb, 2 DD, 2 CA, 1 BB, 3 fht, 1 tac, 2 CV vs 2 DD, 2 CV, 2 CA, 2 BB, 2 fht, 2 tac

att
Rolls: 3@2 5@3 2@4; Total Hits: 33@2: (2, 5, 5)5@3: (6, 6, 4, 6, 3)2@4: (4, 5)

[jim010]

You don’t need to give me losses.

2 BB, 1 CV damaged.

def

Rolls: 4@2 4@3 4@4; Total Hits: 54@2: (5, 5, 4, 3)4@3: (1, 1, 2, 5)4@4: (4, 5, 5, 4)

[Karl7]

Good lord!