G40 League Cow (Allies + 13) vs JuanSpain (Axis) GAME II

[Cow]

So funny I was going to concede instead of posting.  Then I was like wait a second, you kept infantry, when I edited in the aa gun and deleted an infantry. The freaking aa gun hit screw up my attack.

I am not sure what happens when mistakes like this are made. I think I am supposed to reroll it regardless of outcome good or bad for me, because it is not the right unit.

[Cow]

I am sorry about this. I rather not be dishonest. I would have had to reroll it either way because I kept wrong unit for you I think.

If you said AA gun this game probably over. Actually I might have gone nuts with russia first. I am not sure. lol.

[Cow]

I do not know I will ask gamerman if I did right thing. Maybe we have to keep original dice sequence rolled or something, in which case I would have 3 or 4 less infantry.

[JuanSpain]

@Cow:

I am sorry about this. I rather not be dishonest. I would have had to reroll it either way because I kept wrong unit for you I think.

If you said AA gun this game probably over. Actually I might have gone nuts with russia first. I am not sure. lol.

I didn´t open the map to see my decision, did not notice your bombers could reach.

My pacific had many mistakes, lets see the rest of it!

[Cow]

I lost the first attack. I rerolled because you kept infantry and the aa gun had hit my bomber so I could not score hits, this attack I win.

If we keep original dice, with your original decision, I lose 4 infantry I think and we end up trading 7 inf for 7 inf. I pm the moderators asking me what to do.

[Cow]

I seen this happen in another league game I was spectating. I forgot what they did.

[Cow]

Either way I apologize, that aa gun you did not want freaking hit me!

[Cow]

I will post original dice roll sequence to see if that is better for you.

[boldfresh]

the aa hit certainly won’t stand.  i would think the hits juan got on defense with his infantry in the original roll will stand and your attack rolls on the currently posted map will stand.  but of course the decision is gamerman’s.

cheers

[Cow]

5,1

5,3,5,2,6,2,2,2

2,5,3,5,2,2

4,2

6,4,2,1,4,3

~

Round 1 attack 7 inf 2 bomber

5,1

5,3,5,2,6,2,2 =3 hit

defend 7 inf
2

2,5,3,5,2,2  = 4 hit.
attack

4,2

6,4,2, = 2 hit

defend = 1 hit need to roll out rest.

you have 1 roll remaining for this defense.

:20d6:

[Cow]

:roll 20d6:
Rolling 20d6:
(1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 2, 2, 2, 2, 2, 3, 3, 5, 5, 5, 6, 6, 6, 6)

~
Oh that would make more sense if his defense rolls would stand.

[Cow]

So I win with only 1 bomber left in this scenario.

[Cow]

If we just keep the dice Juan rolled for defense
~
5, 1,

2,5,3,5,2,2

6,4,2,1,4,3

6 hits.

[Cow]

ah crap I am missing some dice hold on LOL.

[boldfresh]

whatever you guys decide is fine if you can agree - it only needs to go to gamerman if you don’t agree how to handle it.

cheers

[Cow]

5,1

5,3,5,2,6,2,2,2

5,2,6,1,3,1

5,3,4,4,5

2,5,3,5,2,2

4,2

6,4,2,1,4,3

[Cow]

5,1 5,3,5,2,6,2,2 =3  att

2 5,2,6,1,3,1  = 4 def

5,3,4,4,5  = 1 att

2,5,3,5 = 1 def

2,2 4,2 = 2 att

6,4 2= 1 def

1,4,3= 3 att

you hit defend 1 unit with forum roll.

I win 2 bomber left. Original dice sequence.

[Cow]

That was a headache to do.

[Cow]

Original dice sequence, my aa gun would be in yunnan.

[Cow]

I can see why it would just be a strait up reroll battle. This is a pain and more dice might be needed. I am cool either way.