AARHE: Phase 3: Revised NA's


  • Tekkyy,  you made some errors with copy/paste on the 14. Scorched Earth, you used the text of 7. Schock troops. And the text of Communist Guerillas is double.

    Please correct this…


  • ok done

    now, whats Kesselring about?
    clarify the NA and justify

    I only know he is the General for Germany forces in Italy


  • 14. Kesselring
    For every Italian transport in the Mediterranean, the germans can move one land unit for free in any NCM phase.

    Kesselring had an uncanny ability and skill in extricating himself from the desperate situations. As commander of the Luftwaffe forces he supported Rommel with supplies to aid the latters exploits in Africa. He also organized attacks on Malta to lift the raids on Italian convoys to africa. For this he is listed in the manner appropriate for his skills.

    Eventually he replaced Rommel in the southern front after it was lost. He was the only good thing to come from Italian military leadership because he was a German who understood how to fight war.


  • so whats the Italian transports bit about?
    and is there some restriction (relation to the transports?) to the free movement?


  • so whats the Italian transports bit about?
    and is there some restriction (relation to the transports?) to the free movement?

    Kesselring was commander of the southern front which allocated Both Italian and German supplies, but most of the naval tansport and air transport was italian equipment.

    The attacks on Malta had a dramatic effect on the ability to get supplies to africa… prior to that allied planes from malta sunk alot of this cargo heading to africa.

    This is why you can now move a German infantry to africa… because kesselring was cleaver enough to keep the supply lines open by attacking the Brits in Malta and his organization of logistics to help and support rommel.


  • @Imperious:

    This is why you can now move a German infantry to africa… because kesselring was cleaver enough to keep the supply lines open by attacking the Brits in Malta and his organization of logistics to help and support rommel.

    Yes, that is right. He and Mussoline also had the idea to invade Malta, but Rommel later convinced Il Duce (who could overrule Kesselring) that all efforts should be put in taking Cairo.(after he noticed he was making fast progress in Africa) This is one of Rommels biggest mistakes during the War… (this while when he arrived in Tripoli, he told that without the controll of the airspace over the supply lines, the axis can’t win in Africa…)


  • Maybe replace the U.S. nb. 5 Great Wall NA with;

    5. P-51 Mustang
    The Mustang was a masterpiece of US aircraft engineering. With its Rolls-Royce Merlin engine it could protect bomber squadrons all the way to the target and back. The P-51 flew most of its wartime missions as a bomber escort in raids over Germany, helping ensure Allied air superiority from early 1944.
    Your fighter’s move increases from 4 to 6 on SBR only.


  • For Germany;

    17. Tiger Tank
    The Tigers were originally designed to be offensive weapons but by the time they came into action, the military situation had changed dramatically, so other than a few times, their main use was defensively as tank killers. Some Tiger units exceded the 10:1 kill ratio!!
    During each battle you may assign one tank as a Tiger Tank. The Tiger has 4/4 combat values, and will fire preemptive in defence, and may picks its target ( only ground units)

    I posted this one on Harris, I like it! But can it be put in AARHE??

    18. Amerkia Bomber
    The Amerika Bomber project was an initiative of the Reichsluftfahrtministerium, the Nazi Germany Air Ministry, to obtain a long-range bomber aircraft for the Luftwaffe that would be capable of striking the continental United States from Germany. The Me 264 Amerika (America) was one of the selected aircraft designs to get the job done. Bombing NY city.
    If germany gets both LRA and heavy bombers they can build special bombers (ME 264) that can move to East USA and back to germany ( 10 spaces total)
    This bomber cannot be intercepted nor can ID defense rolls apply. The attacking/defensive values are 5/2 and roll 2 dice on SBR,costing 15 IPC. You have to place a token underneath a Heavy Bomber.

    This is IL’s idea that i tried to make an NA off. Not happy yet about it… Thoughts?


  • For Japan;

    17. Parallel Planning
    During the later half of WWII, the IGHQ amazingly arrived at the same conclusions of American planners, correctly predicting the targets of the Philippines, Iwo Jima, Okinawa and the planned invasion beaches on Japan
    On any Orange territory attacked by the US Player, Japan gets to place 1 free infantry.

    18. Strategic Bombing Limitations
    Since much of Japanese industry were small shops and factories, destroying them was only possible due to overwhelming air power.
    US requires 2 Bombers to conduct Strategic Bombing. They roll only one dice however! (two heavy bombers will roll 2 dice)


  • Tekkyy You only posted half of the 1st NA of Italy in the rule set;

    1. Regia Marina Italiana
    When Italy entered World War II on 10 June 1940 Regia Marina was the fourth largest navy in the world and had a mix of modernised and new battleships. It challenged the Allies, mostly the British Royal Navy, for supremacy of the Mediterranean.
    Once per turn, you may purchase and place one naval unit in Italy for 2 IPC less than cost.

    You wrote;
    1. Regia Marina Italiana
    Once per turn, you may purchase and place one naval unit in Italy for 2 IPC less than cost.

    Please correct this  :wink:


  • 5. P-51 Mustang
    The Mustang was a masterpiece of US aircraft engineering. With its Rolls-Royce Merlin engine it could protect bomber squadrons all the way to the target and back. The P-51 flew most of its wartime missions as a bomber escort in raids over Germany, helping ensure Allied air superiority from early 1944.
    Your fighter’s move increases from 4 to 6 on SBR only.

    ++++++sounds good.

    17. Parallel Planning
    During the later half of WWII, the IGHQ amazingly arrived at the same conclusions of American planners, correctly predicting the targets of the Philippines, Iwo Jima, Okinawa and the planned invasion beaches on Japan
    On any Orange territory attacked by the US Player, Japan gets to place 1 free infantry.

    ++++++would this be for each territory attacked? or just one?

    18. Strategic Bombing Limitations
    Since much of Japanese industry were small shops and factories, destroying them was only possible due to overwhelming air power.
    US requires 2 Bombers to conduct Strategic Bombing. They roll only one dice however! (two heavy bombers will roll 2 dice)

    +++++++I dont see how/where  this is substantiated by any historical example

    17. Tiger Tank
    The Tigers were originally designed to be offensive weapons but by the time they came into action, the military situation had changed dramatically, so other than a few times, their main use was defensively as tank killers. Some Tiger units exceded the 10:1 kill ratio!!
    During each battle you may assign one tank as a Tiger Tank. The Tiger has 4/4 combat values, and will fire preemptive in defence, and may picks its target ( only ground units)

    ++++++ kinda strong… dont we have something on this allready? SS panzers?

    I posted this one on Harris, I like it! But can it be put in AARHE??

    18. Amerkia Bomber
    The Amerika Bomber project was an initiative of the Reichsluftfahrtministerium, the Nazi Germany Air Ministry, to obtain a long-range bomber aircraft for the Luftwaffe that would be capable of striking the continental United States from Germany. The Me 264 Amerika (America) was one of the selected aircraft designs to get the job done. Bombing NY city.
    If germany gets both LRA and heavy bombers they can build special bombers (ME 264) that can move to East USA and back to germany ( 10 spaces total)
    This bomber cannot be intercepted nor can ID defense rolls apply. The attacking/defensive values are 5/2 and roll 2 dice on SBR,costing 15 IPC. You have to place a token underneath a Heavy Bomber.

    ++++++ yea good. Alot of people like the Horton bros. and that flying wing that they made to fly in space and destroy cities. This NA at least in part acknowledges their contribution to the war.


  • Italy: Kesselring
    specify the movement from where to where, or just bridging?
    write the justification text (I can’t find a quick 2 sentence from google for this)

    Italy: Regia Marina Italiana
    where is it missing? its not missing in the previous post

    US: P-51 Mustang
    need to define SBR escorts first
    AARHE only changed two things
    *maximum damage per round equal to territory income
    *defending FTR function as ID in SBR
    (discuss in existing air combat thread here)

    US: Amerika Bomber
    actually need 12 spaces to go from Germany to Eastern US and back?
    unlimited? one BMR only? or one per turn?


  • Italy: Kesselring
    specify the movement from where to where, or just bridging?
    write the justification text (I can’t find a quick 2 sentence from google for this)

    ++++ i posted 4 links… ill get that 2 sentence thing

    Italy: Regia Marina Italiana
    where is it missing? its not missing in the previous post

    +++ repost what you actually have and work it out with Micoon

    US: P-51 Mustang
    need to define SBR escorts first
    AARHE only changed two things
    *maximum damage per round equal to territory income
    *defending FTR function as ID in SBR
    (discuss in existing air combat thread here)

    US: Amerika Bomber
    actually need 12 spaces to go from Germany to Eastern US and back?
    unlimited? one BMR only? or one per turn?

    ====OK make it 12 then… yea just one bomber per turn can do this. You know the Germans had some sub-orbital plane that could have dropped a bomb at such a height and speed that it would have made a huge impact in say new york. They didnt need the A-bomb because the damage from the thing slamming from such a height would have nearly destroyed any city.


  • yea just one bomber per turn can do this

    realistically it/they should be a destinated unit(s)?

    18. Amerika Bomber
    The Amerika Bomber project was an initiative of the Reichsluftfahrtministerium, the Nazi Germany Air Ministry, to obtain a long-range bomber aircraft for the Luftwaffe that would be capable of striking the continental United States from Germany. The Me 264 Amerika (America) was one of the selected aircraft designs to get the job done. Bombing NY city.
    If you have both Heavy Bomber and Long Range Aircraft technology, you may build special BMR (bomber) with 12 movement points. It is immune to ID (infrastructure defence) fire. It attacks at 5 and defend at 2. A maximum of 1 can be on the map at any time. You have to place a token underneath the special unit.


  • About the Regia Marina NA, I checked the downloadable rulebook. Here on the forum you indeed posted correctly.

    17. Tiger Tank, Yes like i sad already myself, not fit for AARHE. We have Heavy tank TECH en SS Panzer NA

    17. Parallel Planning, 1 free INF on each attack.

    18. SBR Limitations, Well this is not mine NA, I took it from Harris’s site (Templeton??) I just added the dice text… But i just googled, and found this;

    The precision targets were not successful, partly due to the lack of fighter cover and partly due to the construction of Japanese factories, refineries and military institutions. Unlike Germany, which required tons of high explosive for each attack, the high explosive from high altitude did not have the same effect on the paper and wood structures predominant in Japan. at; http://worldwar2database.com/html/japanbom.htm

    But the US quickly went over to “firebombing” instead, causing huge damage…  So maybe dump this NA also

    P-51 Mustang, is indeed maybe to much of a struggle to fit into the game. Change to whole combat system for a NA…

    18. Amerika Bomber sounds OK now.


  • Parallel Planning
    after the first time its used in a game, it becomes weird somewhat?

    Great Wall of China
    the only I can find online is that it was used for transportation of troops
    but, weird, at running speed?

    Carpet Bombing
    I think carpet bombing and area bombardment was when precision bombing failed. So instead of targetting military, cities were targetted to demoralise people.
    Maybe US SBR can target VCP instead of IPC?


  • Id go along with Micoons post and proposed changes. that p-51 thing causes too many changes… NA’s should be easy tro understand.

    Tigers are too redundant with other related items ( heavy tanks tech  and SS panzers)


  • So with that being said are we finished with these NA’s?

    If so then if we have any shaky NA’s let people come forward…

    Id still have to resolve the german NA about national redoubt and how this relates to that proposed map change that was posted… what was the decision on that?

    The NA works very well if germany has a southern germany but it also ties in with the italy thing.

    where are we with this?


  • @Imperious:

    So with that being said are we finished with these NA’s?

    yeah just the last issues
    the first message in this page

    Id still have to resolve the german NA about national redoubt and how this relates to that proposed map change that was posted… what was the decision on that?

    The NA works very well if germany has a southern germany but it also ties in with the italy thing.

    how about
    a virtual territory off map for standard map
    southern germany for italy map


  • Parallel Planning
    after the first time its used in a game, it becomes weird somewhat?

    +++ please explain

    Great Wall of China
    the only I can find online is that it was used for transportation of troops
    but, weird, at running speed?

    +++++ if no progress on this then lets remove it.

    Carpet Bombing
    I think carpet bombing and area bombardment was when precision bombing failed. So instead of targetting military, cities were targetted to demoralise people.
    Maybe US SBR can target VCP instead of IPC?

    +++++yea its just the idea of some token way to wack military hardware and not engage enemy land units… thats the basic idea…

Suggested Topics

  • 23
  • 6
  • 7
  • 3
  • 14
  • 6
  • 36
  • 3
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

37

Online

17.0k

Users

39.2k

Topics

1.7m

Posts