13LG40NT Boldfresh (allies +9) vs seththenewb (axis)

[boldfresh]

that’s just BS seth.  but ok whatever.

[seth4god]

@Boldfresh:

i’d rather you just rolled it on tripleA and deleted the first dice or something.� i hate forum rolls unless absolutely necessary.

I couldn’t figure out how to edit you 1 less dude during the battle itself.

[boldfresh]

i am very suspicious of forum rolls.  i don’t really want to keep it.  in fact, i think you should just roll the dice properly through tripleA.

[boldfresh]

tripleA asks you if you want to attack the transports or not.  you must have clicked yes.  all you had to do was click no and you could have run the battle properly.

[seth4god]

@Boldfresh:

that’s just BS seth.� but ok whatever.

What’s BS about it? I stated the issue with the cruiser/bb shots. And told you I was going to edit 1 hit in. I couldn’t do so during the actual battle, so I finished it here.

[boldfresh]

that is an even more BS roll than the volgo battle.

i don’t know seth…  i tell you what i will try it on tripleA and if it works improperly for me i guess i will accept your rolls.  if it works properly, i think you should roll it in tripleA.  if it’s a glitch then fine.

[boldfresh]

yes, it works just fine.  run the battle in tripleA.  i don’t think it’s right that you misclicked then went ahead and ran the battle.  all you had to do was exit and restart and run the battle properly.

[seth4god]

I’ll reroll the battle from the start on the forum if you’d like. But I seriously don’t remember seeing a popup asking about the transports.

[boldfresh]

i mean, if tripleA screwed up that’s one thing - but you screwed up and that’s another.  i prefer that all rolls that can be done through tripleA are done through tripleA.  if tripleA does something wrong, then forum rolls have to be done - but this was not one of them.

[boldfresh]

tell you what - run it again, and if it doesnt ask you if you want to attack the transports or not, then you can keep the previous rolls.

[seth4god]

@Boldfresh:

i am very suspicious of forum rolls. �i don’t really want to keep it. �in fact, i think you should just roll the dice properly through tripleA.

Ask Jenn if you want to, but the forum dice have been accepted as official dice since the start. Would you be complaining about the forum dice if I only hit 1 out of 13? I’m offering to reroll the battle* on the forum if you’d like (since it was pretty bad), but that’s as far as I’m willing to go.

*AAA excluded unless Jenn rules otherwise.

[boldfresh]

why would you want to reroll a battle on the forum when it works properly in tripleA?

[boldfresh]

i’m not saying my dice are the battle.  they weren’t even the right dice since i didn’t take w india.  why don’t you just do the turn in tripleA properly and roll it out?

[boldfresh]

and why does everyone immediately talk about going to the moderator.  and why do you have to use the word “complaining” right away.

you did something irregular and it resulted in me getting screwed.  don’t you think it’s fair to question it in my position?

[seth4god]

@Boldfresh:

why would you want to reroll a battle on the forum when it works properly in tripleA?�

I already rolled it and as far as I know, it was done in a manner that can stand officially albeit somewhat unusual. If you don’t want the reroll then fine, I can conclude my turn. If you want the reroll, I will roll it on the forum so it’s out in the open. If that’s not acceptable to you, then go ask Jenn for another ruling.

[boldfresh]

i mean, if a player does something irregular and it resulted in themselves being
screwed, then to me they are sort of at the mercy of the other player to allow them
to redo something.  but when you misclick in tripleA and then just run it in the forum and i find out the battle could have run correctly in tripleA, i’m not real happy you know?

[boldfresh]

i don’t understand your point - what are you suggesting?  are you saying you would reroll the entire battle on the forum?

[seth4god]

@Boldfresh:

i’m not saying my dice are the battle.� they weren’t even the right dice since i didn’t take w india.� why don’t you just do the turn in tripleA properly and roll it out?

Because the dice have been rolled. It’s simple I’m offering you three choices since you’re taking umbrage with the way I did it.

1. We reroll on the forums
2. The battle stands as is
3. Take it to Jenn

[boldfresh]

oh do you mean you want to keep the rest of the dice from the turn and reroll just this battle on the forum?

[boldfresh]

tell you what, what about a fourth option - we just take the average expected result, edit it in, and call it a day.