Jefe: How is this different from the rules you play with? No one is arguing against the defender choosing his own losses and the attacker choosing his own losses.
Sometimes I think he reads every other line of the post he is questioning. :wink:
Ac ouple questions I had in another post but didn’t mark clearly.
Can I send three fighters in a zone where I know the only landing spot is a carrier knowing that a fighter will get shot down during the battle?
Can a bomber take place in an amphibious assault after a naval battle? The rules clearly state that a fighter cannot, but say nothing about bombers being unable to?
In answer to #1:
No. LZ’s have to exist for everything sent in. “Planning” on losing a fig in terms of counting LZ’s would make 1 of the 3 FIGS a “kazee”
In answer to #2:
Anything NOT used in the naval battle CAN be used for the amphib. The only thing that can participate in the naval battle that also is part of the amphib is the tranny, and that only to offload troops (thus not actually IN the amphib battle).
1 piece, 1 fight, per round.
So if your bomber did not fight in the naval battle, but has the range to reach the amphib attack area, it CAN be used.