I think the issue with this is there aren’t really a lot of “pitched battles” in the Revolution. I think this would need to be more on the lines of the AH “Battlecry” or DOW’s “Memoir '44” based on the commands and colors “engine.”
Time has given us a better view of this question. Who is better between Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford?
They are both as good as the team around them. In other words, they can’t carry a bad team all on their own, but they will help more than hurt a good team that surrounds them.