Could Germany have won "the Great Patriotic War?"

Yeah, but imagine if the German Industry had the chance to produce a large number of Tiger tanks. Those things are fearsome. So were the V2s and Jet Fighters. And hell, the Mg42 is still in use today. The Mp44 and Mp40 were great weapons. And the K43 matched pretty much any rifle the Russians had.

V2s

Hahaha, you mean the V2’s that did more harm then good for Germany? Besides, the Russians were much smarter when it came to rocket technology. Maybe not smarter, but they knew how to put it to good use (Katyusha). Of course this has more to do with mircoeconomy. The V2 hardly carried a payload close enough to doing any real damage.

The Mp44 and Mp40 were great weapons

The Mp40 was not so great of a weapon. It had a tendency to jam and wasn’t very accurate. The STG44 was a good design but only 500,000 were produced and only a fraction of those actually made it to the front lines. Again this has too much to do with mircoeconomy.

Yeah, but imagine if the German Industry had the chance to produce a large number of Tiger tanks

Hahaha, by the time it took to produce one Tiger, The Russians could build 3-5 T-34’s. The Tiger tank was an inferior weapon.

The Russian Department of Weaponry made note of the vehicle’s unreliability in 1944 when it wrote:

“It is suggested to the Red Army to use such German tanks as the StuG III and Pz IV due to their reliability and the availability of spare parts. The new German Panther and Tiger can be used until they are broken down without trying to repair them. They have bad engines, transmission and suspension.”

Due to its heavy armor and heavy 88mm gun, the engine was at its limit to move the tank more than 38kmh/24mph on roads. Also, its overlapping-wheel suspension liked to clog with mud. If the mud froze, the tank would be stranded. Logistically the Tiger was a nightmare – again it was another weapon that did more harm then good. And again, the Tiger tank was a response to Russian improvements in AFV technology.

Macroeconomics was one level Germans could never hope to compete.

Germany’s main problem throughout the war was Hitler’s desire to destroy communism and the Russian people almost as much as Jews. Had he prehaps been overthrown not too late in the war, perhaps a better, more able person could become the next leader of Germany, such as Rommel, who the people already loved. He might have been able to convince the Russians into a peace favorable to Germany and create an actual “1000 year Reich”

When discussing if Germany could defeat Russia in a one-front war, there are many different factors to take into consideration. It could depend on whether Britain simply made peace with Germany or if they were conquered by them in an alternate history where Operation Sealion is launched and suceeds. This would give the German’s the power of England’s Royal Navy and RAF.

Either way, the war would have dragged on for many more years, perhaps even into the 50’s. By then, I believe the more advanced German technologies could give them what they need to win. Despite how dedicated many Russians were for defeating Germany, how willing would they be to fight after witnessing atomic bombs explode over them?

When discussing if Germany could defeat Russia in a one-front war, there are many different factors to take into consideration. It could depend on whether Britain simply made peace with Germany or if they were conquered by them in an alternate history where Operation Sealion is launched and suceeds. This would give the German’s the power of England’s Royal Navy and RAF.

Either way, the war would have dragged on for many more years, perhaps even into the 50’s. By then, I believe the more advanced German technologies could give them what they need to win. Despite how dedicated many Russians were for defeating Germany, how willing would they be to fight after witnessing atomic bombs explode over them?

Heh… pretty unlikely set of “what-if” problems. :-?

I say we come up with a set of rules and restart this topic (Its a fun topic).

For Example:

German Airforce still intact?
German Navy and Uboats still intact?
Egypt Conquered?
What about Japan?