This strategy is basically the same as my “Russian Sacrifice Strategy” that I wrote about in early January. As I mentioned in my thread, Germany’s best chance of defeating it is if they get a good tech early on. Also, in my thread, I assumed that Germany was going all out against Russia by building tanks and bombers so that Russia will fall as quickly as possible (probably turn 4). This strategy keeps India and Australia in UK hands and keeps the Chinese alive. It even keeps part of Russia alive (although admittedly they can’t collect income while their capital is occupied).
Now, I know that most people in my thread stated that it wouldn’t work against a good player. I see the same thing being stated in this thread. Even if that’s true, remember that both Wodan and I are assuming that Russia falls quickly due to Germany building a bunch of tanks and bombers. Every turn beyond turn 4 that Russia survives makes this plan even more effective. If I encountered a German player who built mostly infantry/artillery on turn 1 AND if I were in control of all the allied countries, then I would seriously consider trying it. In fact, I think that against a G1 inf/art build, it’s almost a guaranteed strategy, barring continuous bad dice rolls and/or Germany getting heavy bombers on turn 1. Who knows, the next time I play the allies, I might give it a try.