@Funcioneta:
Hi, Krieg, we are in a bit confusing situation. Tim wants enter with his sub in a sz where I have sub, dd, tra but he wants do it in NCM phase, without attacking them. I think he must attack and kill the dd to enter the sz, but he thinks not. I’m not sure of this, just I’ll link you to the game thread
@Funcioneta:
There is a dd in z23, so you must attack it to enter that sz with the sub. You cannot enter there in NCMs unless you kill the dd first
http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=13098.285
Another thing, can the trannie transport troops if I must leave the sz in case of Tim has right? It must do it in combat phase or in NCM. Thanks
I hadn’t even thought of this until just now. I know you don’t have to move the TRN just because I am there. A sub does not make the sea zone hostile for you. You are free to ignore my sub there for as long as you would like. You should be able to move those boats in either combat or non-combat move as you wish. However, my question would be: IF the DD attacks my sub, does the TRN have to then move in combat move (thus not picking up units unless they unload in hostile territory) either out of the territory or as part of the attack on the sub, or can it do an NCM (moving units to a friendly territory) and the DD does its Attack?
(this all assumes my interpretation of the original question is correct and my sub can be there in the first place :-P )