Thank you for all the great compliments folks! I chose this set for its relatively small number of pieces and it represents one of the battles that most interested me in the pacific campaign.
Guadalcanal night action and long lance torpedos
Commander Hara last edited by
**_I have played the game several times now and find that air power dominates the game to the extent, ships will stand off and not engage. Consequently, a majority of replacement builds are aircraft. Also, there are no provisions for two important elements of the Solomon’s campaign. First, night combat doesn’t exist. A majority of the ship to ship battles took place at night, while aircraft were grounded. Second, there is no inclusion of the long lance torpedo advantage the Japanese cruisers and destroyers had.
I plan on the following:
Play two consecutive turns as night, where all aircraft are grounded. Second, give Japanese CA’s and DD’s a bonus in ship to ship combat. Perhaps a “3” becomes a “2”.
The Americans would have to receive some balancing advantage as well. Radar perhaps, except at that stage of the war it was not very effective or reliable.
Has anyone considered these things and what did you come up with?
Look forward to hearing from you.
Admiral_Thrawn last edited by
Well, I don’t think that the long lance would be that much more of an advantage to have the Japs hit on a 3 or lower. Thats is very powerful. In my experience the ships will stand off too but, battles still occur. Air power should be dominant. Fighters and Bombers become the most powerful weapons of the Navy in WWII. Night fighting is hard. It was a important part of the battle but, is hard simulate in a strategy game with each turn is more than a day.
banshee2200 last edited by
Yes I agree airpower was dominant in the pacific but in this campaign the night actions should be modeled as there were so many such engagements in the slot.
I like the idea of some sort of night rules (long lance, radar etc); I see there is an optional rule for the Japanese to use a nightfighting token but I don’t think this is what Commander Hara had in mind.
Is there a place where these and other suggested “house” rules are being accumulated for A&AG?