AARHE: proposed naval combat rules change


  • Thats what they are supposed to do. THAT should already be in the rules. They are escorts for any type of attack. The allocations are for all types of naval combat


  • @Imperious:

    Thats what they are supposed to do. THAT should already be in the rules.

    Ok thats all good then. I’ll update it.
    Read the file again when you have the time.
    Might pick out more communication errors.

    They are escorts for any type of attack. The allocations are for all types of naval combat

    I thought escorts are only during opening-fire step (because thats when attacks are selective).
    Main round step allocates according to hit allocation chart.

    Should a friendly destroyer be able to take a battleship hit for a friendly battleship?
    If not I would clarify …

    Opening-fire
    Screening
    1. Attacker then defender declare screens for submarine warfare and air combat.
    Submarine Warfare
    1. Attacking then defending SS (submarine) fires.
    2. Attacker then defender performs ASW.
    3. Remove casualties.
    Air Combat
    1. Attacking then defending ships perform Anti-air. Remove casualties.
    2. Attacking then defending air unit’s fire.
    3. Remove casualties.
    Battleship
    1. Attacking then defending BB (battleship) fires.
    2. Remove casualties.
    Main-round
    1. Other attacking sea unit’s fire.
    2. Other defending sea unit’s fire.
    3. Remove casualties.
    Retreat Decision

    The selective fire of air units (in air superiority) and submarines makes it messy if I simplify it further.


  • I think this is how it should look.

    Opening-fire naval combat sequence:

    Submarine warfare
    1. Attacker then defender declare screens for submarine warfare and air combat.
    Submarine Warfare
    1. Attacking then defending SS (submarine) fires at surface ships.
    2. Attacker then defender performs ASW.
    3. Remove casualties from targeted ships.

    Air Combat
    1. Attacking then defending ships perform Anti-air. Remove casualties.
    2. Attacking then defending air unit’s fire.
    3. Remove casualties.

    Battleship
    1. Attacking then defending BB (battleship) fires.
    2. Remove casualties.

    Main-round
    1. Other attacking sea unit’s fire.
    2. Other defending sea unit’s fire.
    3. Remove casualties.

    Retreat Decision


  • yep

Suggested Topics

  • 7
  • 1
  • 32
  • 3
  • 3
  • 14
  • 1
  • 221
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

45

Online

17.0k

Users

39.3k

Topics

1.7m

Posts