Axis and Allies Revised: The Bid


  • Somethign I have often thought about…

    EXCHANGE BIDDING.

    This would be a bid where the extra Axis cash did not come from thin air, but was transfered from the Allies, reducing their first turn income as it raised the Axis first turn (and per-first turn) cash.


  • Nice article NPB, explains bid very well.

    Though Switch, does the allies choose where the money comes from?  Since if I was the allies, I would 90% of the time donate money from America, and if I’m the axis, I would want the money to come from the Soviets.


  • That would allow different flavors to come in with exchange bidding…

    Axis picks the source (bids will be very low).
    Even spread of bids (reduced bids from traditional, but higher than above)
    Allies pick the source (bids slightly reduced from traditional)

    Basically, I would see something liek this happening…

    “Gift” bid (miraculous new money to the Axis, current Method):  Bid in the $7 range common
    Allies pick source:  Bid lowered to $5 range
    Even spread:  Bid lowered to $3-4 range
    Axis picks:  $2

  • 2007 AAR League

    @ncscswitch:

    Somethign I have often thought about…

    EXCHANGE BIDDING.

    This would be a bid where the extra Axis cash did not come from thin air, but was transfered from the Allies, reducing their first turn income as it raised the Axis first turn (and per-first turn) cash.

    thats an interesting concept switch


  • Type above… that should be PRE first turn cash.

    Also, another conept…

    SURRENDER BIDDING.

    Cash to the Axis coming from the Allies, but in the form of TERRITORY (and corresponding income) transfered to the Axis at the start of the game.

    It would ahve to be vacant territory (to preclude the need to re-locate troops which could be its own Allied advantage) is about the only limitation I can think of for this, and that means it would have to come from the UK or USA.  Along with the surrender bid, an additional 1 INF of the nation receiving the bid to be placed in the surrendered territory (just to prevent the surrender bid from being Rhodesia, but with no German troops and UK re-taking with UOSA INF on a walk in on UK1 before Germany could do anythign about it).

  • Founder TripleA Admin

    newpaintbrush,

    Would you mind adding to your article? I think talking more about some of the other used bid systems and some of these proposed ones would be useful.


  • Nice summary on bidding.

    You neglected to mention a widely used bid concept (especially for <pbem>tournaments):

    The blind bid.

    One bid from each side, no room to haggle the amount up or down.  Ties are determined by coin toss.</pbem>


  • How bout the idea of both sides getting X amount of IPC to spend at start, with the axis obviously getting more… Example 3 to 1 ,5 to 2, 9 to 2.  Each side draws chits from a cup with all possible ratios (within reason) the one who draws lowest gets to choose first:

    1. if he wants to take the chit he drew and play those odds as axis or
    2. if he wants to take the allies and play the higher chit drawn by the other person

    This will do a few things:

    1. throw out the silly strategies that stagnate the game where everything is essentially (home preparation)
    2. create totally new strategies and liven the game
    3. make an objectively based system that does not allow game psychology to play a part in the bid.
    4. its also outside the box thinking
  • '18 '17 '16 '11 Moderator

    Switch,

    I think you need to think about a 3rd option as well: Allies can choose where that money comes from.  Maybe they want it all to come from America or split between America and England?


  • I had intended the Allies to choose the source of the bid cash/territories.

    Interesting question…
    Would the USA want to give up Mexico, Cuba, Panama or Brazil from the start?

    Sure, they could take it back, but it would be a detour for US forces from their main goals…

Suggested Topics

  • 14
  • 1
  • 13
  • 1
  • 12
  • 1
  • 4
  • 25
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

66

Online

17.0k

Users

39.3k

Topics

1.7m

Posts