Playing a game on saturday and need help with German Strategy.


  • Just incase this would weigh into the strategy I should use…. I am using Fortress Europe and Atlantic Wall for German NA’s and Dug in Defenders and Tokyo Express for my 2 Japanese NA’s.


  • I totally missed the fact that you mentioned you played with NAs when posted the first couple of times.  But it’s REALLY important.  My bad.

    If you are playing with national advantages, you are gonna get majorly hammered.  Do you know how ridiculous those NAs are?  And you are using MULTIPLE NAs?!  I sure hope the Allies are limited to one random NA each.  But even if they are -

    Superfortresses:  Game-breaking insane.  America buys nothing but bombers and strat bombs Germany.  Shuts Germany down completely, very quickly.  After US builds five bombers (for a total of six bombers), it goes for tech dice Heavy Bombers for added impetus.  Losing 12d6 (Average 42) IPCs per turn with Germany is a REAL PAIN IN THE ASS, and Germany can do ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to stop it.  And it happens by the fourth turn (first turn US builds two bombers and flies one to UK, second turn US builds three bombers and flies the first two to UK, third turn, US flies three bombers to UK and rolls all tech dice, fourth turn, Germany is totally shut down.  Oh yeah, and the US bombers also go around and pulverize the Japanese navy.  15 IPC for two fours?  Man.

    Lend-Lease:  Also game-breaking insane, you get ridiculous fighters from UK, and carry out insanely powerful hit and run attacks on BOTH Japanese and German fronts.  Even if the Allies don’t have superfortresses, all the Allies have to do is a typical KGF.  You have infantry and tanks coming in from UK by the fourth turn, and Russia’s IPC production easily jumps to 45+.  I mean, how ridiculous can you get?

    UK gets Joint Strike, Colonial Garrison, and Radar - all very nice.

    In general, it’s hard for the Allies to get a sucky NA.  Salvage isn’t all that hot.  Mideast Oil isn’t all that useful in most games.  But all the rest of the Allied advantages will give you something nice.

    Some Axis NAs are nice.  Panzerblitz lets you hit and run against USSR, so you can commit your fighters to Western Europe.  Luftwaffe Dive-Bombers isn’t great, you generally don’t want to risk your fighters for half-assed bombing runs (the NA CAN be used, but it is risky as h***).  Rest TOTALLY suck, you are not going to build lots of artillery, and subs are useless against the major problem of having to take Russia down.  But it’s not like Germany has an insanely game-breaking NA like Lend-Lease or Superfortresses.  If the Allies get EITHER one of those, they should kick the c*** out of the Axis.

    Japan - you don’t want to build new destroyers because they’re simply inefficient, and the one you start with will probably die by the end of round one.  Kamikaze and Kaiten are super expensive to use.  Dug-in-defenders is useless, if your infantry is defending on islands (i.e. US overpowered the Jap fleet in the Pacific), you’re dead anyways, and dug-in-defenders just slows the US kick in the face a little.  Lightning Assaults and Banzai are the only useful Jap NAs; you use lightning assault against the top two USSR territories and against multiple territories in Africa.  Banzai lets you build mass infantry and transports in Japan, switch to second IC quickly.


  • My friend is using Colonial Garrison and Radar for GB. I can easily see a way to beat that strategy as he puts the garrison in India.

    I thought that Bomber could not destroy MORE than the value of the territory? That’s how we always played… that would make the most he could take from me 10…

    I know he’s using the Russian Railway one … but that won’t matter much to me because the more attention he pays to east asia the less he’ll have running on the eastern European front.

    I think that me and him like the NA’s mostly because we are really into the history of the war… and it makes it more realistic for us to have the countries having the actual advantages they had in WWII. Some day it would be fun to play with all 6 if you ask me :D


  • Larry Harris Tournament rules limit the total IPC lost per turn to X IPCs per industrial complex, where X is the value of the territory the complex is on.

    But the regular boxed rules and errata do not impose such a limit.  The limit is per industrial complex, per territory value, per BOMBER.  But not per turn.  So EACH heavy bomber can inflict up to 10 IPC of damage.

    Your buddy is running Radar and Colonial Garrison?  That makes India very tough to crack.

    Oh well, I know NAs are fun.  But just remember they’re unbalanced in favor of the Allies.  Heavily unbalanced.

    You should use a bidding system on each game to determine who plays what side.


  • Sadly I have never yet figured out how the bidding system works….

    Also since we use the “IPC’s per territory per countries turn” house rule when we play I am quite content. We play that if GB and the US bomb Germany in the same turn it can lose 10 from each raid.

    But back to this bidding system… how exactly DOES it work?


  • German advantage giving art a defense of 3 is powerful indeed. Gives you a boost of 1/3 to your defense. Think german art boosted as an inf with 3 in defense, 2 in attack and a bonus to a buddy inf. Only at 4 IPC’s. This is very good and makes the german art better than tanks!.

    Sure superfortress and lend-abuse are crazy (and chinese divisions or col garrison), but remember, these are optional rules. Superfortresses can be mended using the A&A Europe rules for strat bombing (escorting planes). Lend- lease can be used as in Europe, only in Russian IC and only in placing new units phase.


  • Today I lost 2 games as the Axis and one as the Allies…. the Allied one was much closer though…

    I guess I’m just not experienced enough… and also just plain unlucky… my opponent would bring 8 pieces from Russia into a territory defened by 5 german pieces only to kill all 5 in one round and suffer NO casualties from my returned fire! That put Germany WAY down… sometimes to below 20 IPCs… though my Japanese navy did very well… I always lost in the end to a combined US GB strike… as colonial Garrison was in effect.


  • "German advantage giving art a defense of 3 is powerful indeed. Gives you a boost of 1/3 to your defense. Think german art boosted as an inf with 3 in defense, 2 in attack and a bonus to a buddy inf. Only at 4 IPC’s. This is very good and makes the german art better than tanks!.

    I stand corrected.  Thanks, funcioneta.


  • I set up the board game at my house last night after I got home …. and I played out my friends R1 against my G1 and it turned out in good favor for the Germans… I guess they are evenly matched strategies… so the luck of the dice plays the biggest factor…

      I think from now on … whether or not I buy an AC should be determined by how many casualties the Russians actually take during their first turn. Does that make any sense?


  • Are you interested in bidding via online dicey’s like DAAK?

    Or just bidding info in general…


  • I was interested in bidding in general for say, a game in my living room.


  • There are a few threads already posted on bidding and how to do it…

    http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=1146.0
    http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=5580.0

    Those should get you started.

    You can also read the essays on the subject at DAAK
    http://www.daak.de/indexe.php?sprache=e
    (click DAAK-club rules along the left side, bidding is the second topic that will come up in the main window)

    That should get you up and running.

    If you still have questions after reviewing those, please feel free to ask :-)

Suggested Topics

  • 3
  • 13
  • 2
  • 33
  • 8
  • 10
  • 5
  • 17
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

32

Online

17.0k

Users

39.3k

Topics

1.7m

Posts