[House Rules] Should allies receive a bid?


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @Mursilis right on. The more ways to play the merrier imo : )

    although I don’t think you can really balance A&A for all skill levels in the same game


  • 2019 2018 2017 '16 '15 '14 Customizer '13

    Ha Ha My lovely G40 game.


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @Mursilis

    I added “Option taamvan” to triplea. It’s under experimental “Global 40 House Rules” .
    Changes the Volgograd, Novgorod, Russia NO to 3 bucks and Caucasus to 3 bucks.

    Adds a Fighter to Russia and a Armor to Urals.

    Rereading taamvan’s post i might have screwed up Caucasus as he says “German” controlled, so Idk if that means Germany has to own it to get the dough and not just the axis, which is the way it is now.

    Also Idk if Italy gets anything for it if they own it then. Probably not. I guess i should ask @taamvan for clarification on that. No biggie to change it.

    I didn’t test much, just enough to see if the stuff showed up so…: )

    Anyway, sounds like a fun twist to things : )

    Peace Out

    Oh yea, so go to “Map Options” before you start the game to get to it.



  • @barnee
    Hey thanks for putting the effort in but it doesn’t seem to be working for me. I’m in global house rules and checked the taamvan option in the map options menu. I started the game and it had the changer round. I opened up the game tab and went to map options and it showed that taamvan was checked but no tank in urals and no extra fighter in russia. 😞


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @Mursilis yea the fighter and tank don’t show up until after Germany’s politics phase

    I’ll see if i can activate it a little sooner.


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @Mursilis

    Ok I fixed it so the Fighter and Tank will show up on Game start. Just delete and re DL. Version 2.3 is what you want.

    Sorry about that. I musta been high when I did that last night : )



  • I like the idea of the teamvan houserule. What other house rules are on TripleA? Is there a Grasshopper G40 or 3G40 option available? Is perhaps even a HBG Global War game available on TripleA?


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @Mursilis well I fck’d up again. : )The NO’s disappeared. I’ll get it straightened out. Might want to stay with the 2.2 one for now.

    @DCWhat Hi DC
    Don’t know of any of YG’s stuff on triplea, although some of the House Rules may overlap. BM is probably the most popular that’s on triplea.

    The House Rule mod is just a bunch of House Rules that people have come up with over the years so people can use the ones they want.

    link text

    explains a lot of it


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @Mursilis well not sure what’s happening. On my linux machine the NOs show up. On windows it doesn’t, although the game plays correctly with the PU total at 3. They just don’t show up in the Objectives tab the way they do on the linux machine.

    So 2.3 is the same as 2.2 in that regard. The Objectives doc is the same with the new NOs in it.


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @Mursilis
    I put the cap back on the glue and it’s all sorted now. Actually the Canada Mod was the one not showing up, so shouldn’t affect you anyway. 2.4 is the latest.

    Oh yea @DCWhat there are some alternate setups with no rule changes. oztea’s 41 being the best imo. It comes with the Global dl. Worth a spin if you haven’t tried it.



  • @barnee
    Excellent, thank you.


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @Mursilis Right on. Let us know how your game goes.


  • 2019 2018

    Perhaps we ought to beseech the maker for a global 1940.3 game in a single box, with a new map, with two new components (like a tech tree and generals) and an official handicap system like golf has?


  • 2018 2017

    Dave says we should work on our Operation: Market Garden variant.



  • Well this thread went a bit off topic.

    It is very clear that the consensus is if two players are equal in skill, the allies should receive a bid.

    The real issue is determining how much of a bid, and If it is even necessary. IMO the only real way to tell if your opponent needs a bid, is if you have played each other before. While I do think it is common curticy to offer a bid to the allies, you dont actually know if more or less IPCs are needed, more often than not.

    What I suggest the community should do is agree on a SET bid for a standard match between two players(or teams) that have never faced each other before. Then sticky the rule so new comers can see it.

    All of my games are on tabletop. I play with multiple groups of varying skill level. I would suggest that if your groups skill level varies, keep the best players on separate teams, and try to balance the teams as best as possible, before considering a bid.


  • 2019 2017 '16

    @ReturntoNES Sounds like you’re really looking for a setup change.



  • @simon33 well sure I am. But that isn’t the topic of this thread…


  • 2018 2017

    @ReturntoNES

    That’s what I proposed; removing the choice so that there is a ‘set bid’ (1 Rus Armor and 1 Rus Fighter out of range of the opener), and its a setup change as well.

    I agree with you, that a bid wouldn’t always be necessary, but different players show up each week. Often, we assign players or roll for teams; as I keep pointing to the club out this process is the opposite of open bidding, and once the teams are established by rolling or preference you have to simply designate a bid, which we agree is about 10-20 IPC.

    At least in my live games, the need for a high bid is much lower than the ABH reported bids in the league. One on one vs Dave (who I consider better than myself), i’d want at least the “Taamvan Mod” amounts listed here (reduce (4x)5 bonuses to 3, add rus tank rus fighter)


  • 2019 2018 2017 '16 '15

    I didnt understand all of this, but is there an available option to play the “taamvan mode” on triple a. In case how do I find it?


  • 2020 2019 2018

    @oysteilo

    yea go to map downloads, experimental. “Global 40 House Rules” is what you want.

    Then hit “Map Options” before game start and hit “Option taamvan”. Latest version is 2.63. Idk if that will conflict if you play against someone with an earlier version.

    The changes since didn’t have anything to do with the “taamvan” option, so I’d think you’d be okay, but…



  • So I have played two games with the “taamvan mode” and I think that it does quite good job at balancing out the game. It slightly slows down Germany while giving the Soviet Union something it never had before. OPTIONS!
    That extra tank and fighter can be in Manchuria by turn 3 which means that not only does this effect Germany but also Japan. Hitting Manchuria/Korea with 18 infantry a tank and fighter means that Japan has to spend more money on transports or turn around some land units or simple keep a larger force than usual in Manchuria.

    I think it is a small change that makes a big difference and I encourage everyone to give it a try.



  • There is something to be said for fixed bids, or bids that is added to a nations starting money.

    one problem with bids you can place where you want is that there are critical units you get to place. as an example, going from allied bid of 5 to 6 is much more impactful than 1 ipc. It allows UK to place that sub in the med. If a bid of 5 meant getting 1 AA in UK, and a bid of 6 meant getting 1 inf in UK and 1 inf in Moscow, the difference would not be as significant.


  • 2018 2017

    @Mursilis

    Thanks Mursilis, it only took me 191 games and 2 mod attempts to come up with that simple solution. We are getting into more “late games” where things aren’t decided until after the fall of moscow. If Germany survives the fall of moscow with most or all of its planes, and 5 or so tanks, with the OOB bonuses on top of that, it will almost always win. Argo has convinced me that Moscow will fall in the majority of games. The Ger/Italy money and starting forces simply cannot be stopped. The questions then are

    1. did UK West build 3 factories, early? Did they waste money on anything but factories and plugging troops into the ME?
    2. Does Germany have so much money and income after the fall of moscow such that with 4 eastern factories and what survived, it can handily a) take london because the defenders left b) take egypt by overwhelming the whole game build of UK west with the just the survivors and the late game build of Germany?

    In the OOB game, Germany just needs to be patient, and it will eventually win. This is because they have like 80+ and a bunch of free bonuses and factories, whereas UK at most has 50 and usually more like 40 to fuel 3-4 factories. Russia cannot take Iraq or Persia–it will never have the $$ to build that many units and once its taken them, UK cannot do so. Japan can get shut completely down and this dynamic doesnt change.


  • 2018 2017

    This is also why taking cyprus or malta is so powerful—denying the UK that bonus all game is another 50 dollars in 10 turns



  • @taamvan
    I am wondering if you do Gargantua’s start as Soviet Union which is 6 tanks and building tanks and a few arty with infantry. Tank spamming with the SU is a must for countering the Germans. I was also wondering if you considered making Leningrad worth 5 again since this would make a northern push a bit more desirable since a problem with the game for the germans is that there is a TON of money south and not much north, plus you are further away from moscow. What are your thoughts?


Log in to reply
 

Suggested Topics

  • 2
  • 18
  • 6
  • 8
  • 3
  • 30
  • 4
  • 8
I Will Never Grow Up Games
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures
Dean's Army Guys

49
Online

14.4k
Users

34.9k
Topics

1.4m
Posts