@Baron:
@Dauvio:
Hi guys, I have given a lot of of thought on Young Grasshopper’s 8D proposal, and this is what I came up with.
INF C3/M1/A1/D2
ART C4/M1/A2/D2
MECH C4/M2/A1/D2
TANK C6/M2/A4/D4
FIGHTER C10/M4/A4/D5
T-BOMBER C11/M4/A4/D4
S-BOMBER C12/M6/A6/D2
BATTLESHIP C20/M2/A6/A6
CARRIER C16/M2/A0/D3
CRUISER C12/M2/A5/D5
DESTROYER C8/M2/A2/D2
SUB C6/M2/A2/D1
INF C3/M1/A1/D2
ART C4/M1/A2/D2 18.0 powerhit
MECH C4/M2/A1/D2
TANK C6/M2/A4/D4
FIGHTER C10/M4/A4/D5
T-BOMBER C11/M4/A4/D4
S-BOMBER C12/M6/A6/D2 6.00 powerhit
BATTLESHIP C20/M2/A6/A6
CARRIER C16/M2/A0/D3 4.42 powerhit
CRUISER C12/M2/A5/D5
**DESTROYER C8/M2/A2/D2 4.5 powerhit
SUB C6/M2/A2/D1** 8.00 or first strike: 12.00, 4.00 or first strike: 5.32 power*hit
I bolded the difference between you and YG.
That might be interesting to know why you prefered these values.
For instance, DD does not defend as well as Carrier.
I suggested D3 for both, YG kept A3 D3 for DD but D2 for Carrier.
Here is YG’s complete D8s roster:
Inf A1-2 D2 strength 16.0 or 32.0
MI A1-2 D2 strength 9.0 or 18.0
Arty A3 D2 strength 27.0, 18.0
Tank A4 D4 strength 16.0
AAA A0 D1*
Fighter A4 D5 strength 5.76, 7.20
TcBomber A4-5 D4 strength 5.95 , 4.76
StBomber A5 D1 strength 5.00 , 1.00
Submarine A3 D2 strength 12.00, first strike 18.00, 8.00 first strike 10.64
Destroyer A3 D3 strength 6.75
Cruiser A5 D5 strength 5.00
Carrier, 2 hits A0 D2 strength 2.95
Battleship A6 D6 strength 3.77
Here is the value based on 12 IPCs Cruiser put at 5.00 as the benchmark for YG numbers.
Formula is 144*power/Cost^2.
*2.618034 for 2 hits Battleship or Carrier
If Battleship was A7 D7 C20, you would get a strength factor of 6.60 powerhit.
If Destroyer is A2 D2 C8, you would get 4.5 powerhit.
2 hits Carrier A0 D3 C16 is 0.00, 4.42 power*hit
Comparison:
Infantry A1-2 D2 M1 C3: 16.00 / 32.00
Mech Inf A1-2 D2 M2 C4: 9.00 / 18.00
Artillery A2 D2 M1 C4 : 18.00 / 18.00
Artillery A3 D3 M1 C4 : 27.00 / 27.00
Tank A4 D4 M2 C6 : 16.00 / 16.00
YG Arty+Inf combos: Attack: 29.39 Defense: 23.51
Vann Arty+Inf combos: Attack/Defense: 23.51
YG Arty+MechInf combos: Attack: 22.5 Defense: 18.00
Vann Arty+MechInf combos: Attack/Defense: 18.00
YG’s StBomber A5 D1 C12: 5.00 , 1.00
Vann’s StBomber A6 D1 C12 6.00, 1.00
YG’s Destroyer A3 D3 C8: Attack/Defense: 6.75
Vann’s Destroyer A2 D2 C8: 4.5
YG’s Submarine A3 D2 strength 12.00 first strike 18.00, 8.00 first strike 10.64
Vann’s 8.00 or first strike: 12.00, 4.00 or first strike: 5.32 power*hit
YG’s 2 hits Carrier A0 D2 strength 2.95
Vann’s 2 hits Carrier A0 D3 strength 4.42 power*hit
YG’s Carrier+ 2 Fgs A8 D12 C36 strength: attack 4.65 defense 5.33
Vann’s Carrier+2 Fgs A8 D13 C36 strength: attack 4.65 defense 5.78