UK-India falls,….????Automatic Capture of other UK-Pacific countries????

  • Customizer

    Guys,

    @Kreuzfeld:

    this is not an unusual situation at all. in basicly every game paris is taken. Then you can only gain controll over the french terretories with UK if the axis have taken it first. I hope there are not many people out there allowing uk to take all the french terrs south of sahara, bumping their income.

    ––We have never allowed territories of subjugated countries to be controlled unless through combat with an enemy. I merely wanted a definite, official answer to back up my opinion to the Anzac player,…who was somewhat new to the game.

    “Tall Paul”


  • Tall Paul

    It was not my intention to sound sarcastic. I genuinely wanted to know how long you have been playing this game for. The reason for that was because I assuming you have been playing for a long time. Which you confirmed since 1984. If you have been playing since 1984 you would know that allies cannot attack each other. You also asked that when Japan took and subjugated India if Anzac could then automatically capture the territories it was currently in. Based on this question and assuming you knew the rule that you could not attack allies. I thought you played as if when you lose your capital all the lands went to the conqueror. As in UK Pacific is now subjugated and loses control of its territories as you put it. After my misunderstanding was corrected. I then based my answer around your question as if japan didn’t take the rest of your lands. And still basically gave you the same answer because it still answers your question if not directly to your exact scenario. That territories only change hands when an enemy captures it. ANZAC is an enemy of Japan. so them taking Japanese held British lands is an enemy taking a land. How is this statement false?

    You then began to basically bash me and claim all my statements were just opinions. Opinions that were false and sarcastic….Which they weren’t. Or at least not intended to be sarcastic.

    Krieghund confirmed my understanding of the rules were Correct. Yet you claimed them false. And then later claiming you knew all along after they were confirmed, saying it was just for a newbie. Which is it?
    1. You didnt know, or
    2. you knew and were annoyed with me because i gave you an “un-official” answer, misunderstood you and thought i was a prick. So you then began to bash me.

    If you knew the answer you would not claim my statements false and would have said " Sorry Gliven i will wait on an Official answer from Krieghund. "

    So if its number 2 and you just wanted to bash me…common…how old are you? And no. this time i don’t really care how old you are…

    I used to enjoy reading your posts Tall Paul…but after this…ehhh not so much.

  • Customizer

    Gliven,

    ––I don’t wish to argue with anyone. That was the reason that I wanted an “Official” answer as I knew things could easily be misunderstood or misinterpreted. I truly hold no grudges against you or anyone else, and hope you don’t against me. I can understand how statements made via computer can be misunderstood, like when I misunderstood your responses for “sarcasm”. I’m sorry I did so, but let’s not worry about things like that and simply enjoy this wonderful game.
    ----I wasn’t “bashing” you,…just refuting your statements that weren’t correct for the example I was involved in.
    It seems we both misunderstood each other’s sentiments. I’m sorry,…and you’ve already said the same. So I hope we can leave it there,….OK. I’m a friendly guy, certainly not perfect, but not a jerk, either.
    ----The somewhat “new” player that was playing Anzac has a forceful type of personality that sometimes interprets rules incorrectly and then is very VOCAL in his viewpoint. Sometimes he’s only interested in “interpretations” that help his armies. I simply thought it best if I gave him some “Official” proof that his interpretation was incorrect so that’s what I did.

    Respectfully,
    “Tall Paul”


  • Tall Paul,

    I would like to apologize once again, this time for also misunderstanding you. I guess i got a little “emotional” for lack of a better term. I’m not perfect myself.

    I do not hold a grudge against you.

    I wish you good luck and good fun in your match against your opponent.

    So yes lets leave it at this.

  • Customizer

    Gliven,

    ––There’s no need for any apology. We simply misunderstood each other. Have a good day.

    Respectfully,
    “Tall Paul”

Suggested Topics

  • 5
  • 9
  • 34
  • 15
  • 25
  • 28
  • 7
  • 44
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

52

Online

17.0k

Users

39.3k

Topics

1.7m

Posts