I voted 9-10 based on how much fun it has been to play the game. It’s really the first totally new A&A game since the original was released in 1984. All permutations on the 1984 game have tweaked the general concept, but the way you play the game is generally the same. This game, however, is completely different due to the 1 round only combat model and the fact that it’s just a different war, with different alliances, etc.
My only issues with the game are minor, but I will note them again in passing:
1. Poland should not have a coastline (map issue). I think it’s fairly easy to make a house rule that will change that for game play purposes, not that it’s ever come up in any of the games I’ve played.
2. I do think maybe tanks should be available in Turn 3, and it may make sense to reduce their cost to 5.
3. It may make sense to reduce cruisers to 8.
Other than that, now that rules have been changed and clarified, the game is fantastic.