Ruling Question



  • I read a ruling on this once, but i can’t remember the answer.  If Germany invades Canada does this allow the USA to make a declaration of war?



  • I need another ruling as well.  If there are two German U-boats in SZ 106 (using Alpha 2 rules), do they cut 3 IPCs total: 1 from New Brunswick and 2 from Quebec?



  • @Pherman1215:

    I need another ruling as well.  If there are two German U-boats in SZ 106 (using Alpha 2 rules), do they cut 3 IPCs total: 1 from New Brunswick and 2 from Quebec?

    We play this as a loss of 3 ipc’s and I don’t see why it wouldn’t. But it would be nice to hear a conformation from the big wigs.



  • @Pherman1215:

    I read a ruling on this once, but i can’t remember the answer.  If Germany invades Canada does this allow the USA to make a declaration of war?

    Yes



  • @Pherman1215:

    I need another ruling as well.  If there are two German U-boats in SZ 106 (using Alpha 2 rules), do they cut 3 IPCs total: 1 from New Brunswick and 2 from Quebec?

    Yes (alpha +2 only).



  • Another odd question:

    So, I was mad at Russia for not retreating his Siberian stacks so I attacked him.

    Russia believed that if he didn’t declare war on me (but didn’t retreat) and then on J1 I declared war, attacking the Mongolian territories J1 would’ve been attacking a strict neutral. Is that correct?



  • @techroll42:

    Another odd question:

    So, I was mad at Russia for not retreating his Siberian stacks so I attacked him.

    Russia believed that if he didn’t declare war on me (but didn’t retreat) and then on J1 I declared war, attacking the Mongolian territories J1 would’ve been attacking a strict neutral. Is that correct?

    Yes, even if Japan attacks a Mongolian territory plus Amur during the same combat phase, the strict neutral rule is activated. The decision to retreat or not won’t effect territory status in this case.



  • OK thanks, guess I was wrong but we settled on the right decision!


Log in to reply
 

Suggested Topics

  • 8
  • 4
  • 3
  • 4
  • 12
  • 3
  • 2
  • 14
I Will Never Grow Up Games
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures
Dean's Army Guys

44
Online

13.7k
Users

34.1k
Topics

1.3m
Posts