Quote
Not until 1943 and as you stated this is a 1941 comparison, so Duke of York is off the list.
How does that make ANY sense?
]
Because this is not “back to the future” comparison :roll:
The Missouri never sunk a ship. � Ever.
This is a 1941 Matchup.
YOU argued that this is only a comparison of 1941 Battleships and that if the ship didn’t exist or didn’t sink anything by that time, it is not part of the list.
Of course nobody agrees with that logic, but it was perhaps some way to make a point even if the facts latter shot it down.
YOU said this is a comparison of 1941 Battleships and the prerequisite was they needed to sink a compatible ship to qualify for the comparison. Irregardless of how stupid and asinine that logic is if you want to stick to your fact pattern Duke of York is not a candidate because by 1941 it didn’t sink ANYTHING. GET IT?
So in a theoretical matchup, we can only talk about match-ups that ACTUALLY occurred in 1941? that’s stupid.
THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT YOU SAID. You said it had to have sunk a ship by 41.
Quote
Battleships do not have “complacency” they are objects and this is a comparison of 1941 Battleships according to YOU, not the Management of how these ships were employed.
Ok professor, take your ship with no crew on it, and put it up against my ship with a fully trained crew on it, and see who wins.
A ship is only as good as her crew, which is more than capable of complacency.
NO you got it wrong again. To compare a Battleship with another you just compare the attributes of the ships. The crew was not built with the ship and this is not a comparison of crews.
Don’t be ridiculous. You compare speed, armor plating, fire control, guns, etc
A ship is only as good as her crew
So i guess you can never compare any tank because all tank crews are different?
I guess you can never compare a fighter or bomber because THE CREW JUST gets in the way of any comparison because they are all different.
WOW what precision and logic!
I guess you cant compare cars or trucks, since that driver makes all the difference. I guess we don’t need GD Power anymore… :roll:
Quote
Probably all the Battleships sunk after 1941 were because of American naval and air forces.
What about the TIRPITZ you just pointed out?
Probably hey? Wow…
What about basically the entire Japanese navy. Which is more? Tirpitz of the Japanese navy.