Axis and Allies: Victories and the Victor Poll


  • Well, the allies won the last game I played, but it was due to an axis surrender, not a VC victory. In fact, most games are surrendered before a VC victory.

    BTW, China could capture Hong Kong or Shanghai to win the game


  • But they can’t take a capital, which is how the Allies win. Right? Did I misread the rules again…?

    I’m not sure this poll will work the way I want it to. I’m completely new to Forum Polls.

    EDIT: Well, you could just give the victory to whichever nation contributed most to the victory.


  • @hewhoisnickel:

    But they can’t take a capital, which is how the Allies win. Right? Did I misread the rules again…?

    I’m not sure this poll will work the way I want it to. I’m completely new to Forum Polls.

    EDIT: Well, you could just give the victory to whichever nation contributed most to the victory.

    You’re right


  • good idea for a poll.  I think it will give us something a little more scientific to think about when people complain that the game is broken because they can never win as a certain country.


  • And is anyone able to vote more than once? If not, I’ll reset the poll every (30? Does that seem about right?) voters and keep track of the numbers.


  • USA ignored Japan. Japan was able to get to the USA before Italy and Germany.

  • TripleA

    @hewhoisnickel:

    And is anyone able to vote more than once? If not, I’ll reset the poll every (30? Does that seem about right?) voters and keep track of the numbers.

    i think the polls are broken. a while back i tried to set up a poll to see which side was winning more. when i set up the poll i was given the option to allow multiple votes. but when people went to vote they were only allowed to vote once.


  • I think that option simply allows you to select multiple options when you vote. Not that you can vote multiple times.


  • OK, so I guess I’ll just reset it every time it gets to 30. Thanks guys. Exact same rules apply.

    Does 30 sound like a good amount, by the way?


  • I reset the poll to zero. Everyone can vote again. Only vote if you haven’t voted yet or if you’ve played a game since the last time you voted. Thank ya all very much.


  • USA took in order: Roma, Berlin et Tokyo.
    Big victory for the Allies!  :-D

    Sorry for the language, I have a little problem with my computer… :x

  • '20 '18 '16 '13 '12

    Superbe! Et bienvenue a la communaute de AA.org

    And thanks for the poll nickel. I hope it sheds some clear light on the balance in the game.

    Also this is assuming we played with the OOB setup or the new suggested Pacific setup from Larry Harris?


  • @Canuck12:

    Superbe! Et bienvenue a la communaute de AA.org

    And thanks for the poll nickel. I hope it sheds some clear light on the balance in the game.

    No problem! I thought with all of the claims that the game was broken and such, I’d try to see if they were right.

    @Canuck12:

    Also this is assuming we played with the OOB setup or the new suggested Pacific setup from Larry Harris?

    I didn’t really think about that. I play the OOB because my group is somewhat hesitant about the complexity and hugeness of the game, so I try to keep it simple, but I assume that it’s about half and half on AA Forums. So, either one, I suppose. Is this a problem?


  • Bump. Gotta keep people voting!


  • Hmm. People are now misusing the poll. There are 16 total voters and about 28 votes. Should I remake the poll?


  • I am remaking the poll to disable cheating and switching over the data so far. Please do not post on this thread again. If any admins have the ability, lock this thread. Thank you.

Suggested Topics

  • 40
  • 1
  • 616
  • 30
  • 31
  • 8
  • 14
  • 30
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

33

Online

17.0k

Users

39.3k

Topics

1.7m

Posts