The red I posted was Larry’s summary of others in the long pages of posts. I actually do not agree with everything in red in my previous post, I just wanted to jump start the brainstorming.
At this point, I could keep the current rules with a small change of damage (3 +1d6).
or just 2d6.
A lot is going on at the Larry Harris site and I wanted more participation by members of this forum.
Many of us do not post at the other site very often.