Is this the worse game?

[Dylan the Canadian]

I played G40, E40, P40, 1942, Classic, Revised, D-day, Anniversary, and 2nd Edition

My order of my favorite:

G40
E40 (just slightly better than P40)
P40
Anniversary
1942
Revised
D-day
Classic
2nd Edition

Dunno, but in my opinion P40 is too unbalanced. I'd also probably put the Anniversary addition over E40.

[wittmann]

We have not played more than 3 games. Cannot really get our heads around the different rules.  When will we get a Kursk or Stalingrad? My wife loves BOTB too!

[Yavid]

We have not played more than 3 games. Cannot really get our heads around the different rules.  When will we get a Kursk or Stalingrad? My wife loves BOTB too!

You're a lucky man, My wife banishes me to the basement and complains but me playing board games. But I think one or two board games is better than a new video game every 3 months and new system every 2 years

[hkytown1]

Guad would be the best game if they dumped the dice box and let Variable re-write the rules.  Actually, he has already done that with the "Battle of Midway" game.   It's too bad that this game usually sits on our shelves.

[wittmann]

I agree. Would love to like it and to play it sometime. Have not for 2 or 3 years